Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts

Monday, April 24, 2017

What Science Ain't

I sparked a bit of an argument on social media with a little jab at Bill Nye the Scientism Guy.
Bill Nye the Science Guy is a science expert in the sense that Larry the Cable Guy is cable expert.
People don't really like it when you attack their cherished sciensh celebrities. The reaction of those who chose to defend the attack was what we've come to expect: a discussion of credentials. For instance, because Nye is a degreed mechanical engineer, that makes him a qualified scientist. More than just a fictional character with a children's show, I suppose. But is he a scientist? What is a scientist? To find out, let's name the things we know aren't scientists and see where things start to get uncomfortable.

A tech junkie is not a scientist

There's a tendency for people to lump all technology in with science. For instance, people say that because engineering is a subset of science, engineers are scientists. But does working in technology make one a scientist? By that understanding, gadget gurus would have to be scientists, as well as mathematicians, etc. If all STEM is science, then why even have the TEM at all? It should just be S.

A book reader is not a scientist

Merely possessing knowledge does not make one a scientist. An idiot savant whose only skill is voracious reading skills coupled with perfect retainment might learn the entirety of some scientific discipline in a number of months. But that would not make him a scientist. Learning science does not count. I've taken quantum mechanics but no one pretends I'm a physicist.

A figure skater is not a scientist

Further, employing knowledge found from science does not make one a scientist. A figure skater might be a top-notch scholar, with a deep understanding of the laws of centripetal motion.  She might employ that knowledge to create visually stunning performances of her art. But that does not make her a scientist. An engineer is not a scientist just because he builds bridges. If they were, they'd have to build a series of spans at each crossing to determine which design & materials had the best results. But they don't do that. They build bridges using best design practices and knowledge previously acquired.

A teacher is not a scientist

Teaching is not science. Teaching is teaching. Science might be applied to teaching, but that is not the norm. Science is about discovering new information. Teaching is about passing the information down to others. Both are very important roles, but they are not the same. Just because Nye goes in front of kids and recreates science experiments does not make him a scientist any more than performing Beethoven makes a pianist a composer.

A computer scientist is not a scientist

The term science has been so abused that it cannot be trusted on sight. People have a tendency to latch on to the word in the belief that it will convey an air of legitimacy. But not much of what happens in the field of computer science is really science. The same can be said of political science and probably any field that feels compelled to include the word science. Computer science graduates understand the distinction and call themselves programmers or software engineers instead. Even within academia, they are more likely to refer to themselves as researchers than scientists.

A taxonomer is not a scientist

Here things start to get uncomfortable, as taxonomy is defined as a field of science. Is it really science? It doesn't do much to expand the field of human knowledge. Then again, organizing things allows for humans to perceive relationships they might otherwise miss. I would suggest that taxonomy can be a science, as long as it organizes observations against a testable theory. For instance, I might organize my record albums by the middle name of the drummer, but there is nothing to test. There is no underlying theory. I might theorize that all the K albums will be terrible, but testing random hypotheses probably doesn't constitute science.

On the other hand, organisms tend to be organized according to the theory of evolution. It is tested every time a new organism is discovered (does it fit in nicely or does it mess up the order?) and with the advent of new technologies, such as genomics. So a taxonomer might actually be a scientist, but we have a pretty good idea of when they are not.

A theoretician is not a scientist

Are theory guys scientists? What about philosophers and logicians? Our theory of science probably shouldn't exclude theoretical physicists, but what if it does? The job of the theorist is to create hypotheses. We might make a similar argument as we did of the taxonomer. Their work must be testable. String theory has lost support in the scientific community; no one believes it is a testable theory.

Can we apply the same requirement to the logician or the philosopher? I reckon there is no other way. Arm-chair philosophers might analyze their world view and come up with unique insights, but the process can only be called science if those insights are testable. In Make Predictions or STFU I implored anyone making social commentary to make predictions if they expect to be taken seriously. To be credible, one must be regularly proven correct, or show that they have modified their world view in response to poor predictions. This prediction-making is a poor man's science. Yes, it's prone to some confirmation bias, but formal science suffers that as well. Perhaps even more so, as disagreeing with the academic orthodoxy is a good way to sink a promising research career.

Bill Nye is not a scientist

Perhaps science is not really that complicated to define after all. Actions that expand or sharpen the collection of testable human knowledge is science. Everything else is something else. Acquiring scientific knowledge isn't science. Applying scientific knowledge isn't science. Teaching scientific knowledge isn't science. It would seem that there isn't anything that Bill Nye does that could actually be called science. Making and testing predictions on a blog is closer to science that what Bill Nye does, which is to apply pseudo-scientific rationale to preferred political and social objectives. We all tend to do it, but we don't all have a large platform to broadcast from or the veneer of scientific credibility. Really Bill Nye is a model for us of what not to be doing.

Science is a process. You are a scientist if you engage in science. Having a degree doesn't make you a scientist. Advocating science doesn't make you a scientist. However, to go back to my initial point, the question was never whether Nye is a credentialed scientist, or even whether he is a scientist at all. The question was whether he is a science expert. Can one be an expert in a field of which they do not participate? Yes, I think they can. Historians of medieval warfare don't normally engage in jousting tournaments to prove their legitimacy, for example.

So how do we know if Bill Nye is a science expert? Well if we could definitively answer that question then we could also answer a great number of more substantive problems. Like who to elect. The normal human intuition must suffice. Does he have great command of the science he discusses? Does he communicate that knowledge without contradicting himself? Is he able to make solid arguments in favor of the positions he advocates? The answer to all those questions, as shown in Bill Nye the Scientism Guy, is no he does not. He does not have the facts of climate change at his disposal. He deeply contradicts himself. And not only are his arguments easily refuted, they betray a novice grasp of the concepts he using. If he goes on Tucker Carlson specifically to talk about cognitive dissonance and then shows that he doesn't really understand the term, then what else is he talking about that he does not understand? 

It's interesting that Bill Nye is arguing that climate skeptics are suffering cognitive dissonance because they question the results of the academy, and so many people defend Nye because he is (allegedly) credentialed. It all sounds like the sort of dynamic that science was supposed to avoid. In the days before science, the epistemological orthodoxy was strictly controlled by the academy, which was basically the church. While the anti-science role of the church is somewhat exaggerated in the modern zeitgeist, it can't be denied that they kept a strong grip on what could be believed and what would be punished as heresy. The whole point of science was that knowledge became a matter of provable fact rather than theological or authoritarian belief. And yet here we are, being told that consensus of the academy is all the proof we need, and academic credentials are all that convey credibility. By the same people, mind you, who typically condemn religion because of it's enforced monopoly on intellectual discourse. It seems that too many of those people are less interested in destroying religion as a matter of  principle as they are in replacing it with their preferred religious orthodoxy, Scientism.

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

Discussion of March for Science Analysis

In March for Science I analyzed the march organizers' own promotional materials to determine what interpretations of science they are predominately marching for. One conclusion was that the second highest motivation was influencing policy with science. That shouldn't be surprising as a March on Washington is quite likely to be about influencing policy. Influencing policy with science sounds like a no-brainer, but what are they really advocating for? There are different ways to look at influencing policy with science.

The truest interpretation of science is as a process. Not as a body of knowledge, or a community, or a philosophy or belief system, but as a method used to strain objective truth from the murky soup of human observations and beliefs. The most straightforward influence of science on policy making is to incorporate scientific inquiry into the political process. It is the scam of the modern era that our allegedly scientific society does not directly apply science to the task of policy making. How can we truly know the effects of policy in highly complex fields like healthcare if we aren't experimenting and measuring results? There is a single informal method of A/B testing in policy, which was granted to us by the Founding Fathers in the form of federalism. States' rights allow for the simultaneous implementation of various policy approaches that can be analyzed for effectiveness. Yet liberals who are organizing the march have very little interest in states' rights, except for when they provide immediate and narrowly scoped support to causes such as marijuana legalization and gay marriage. But those are exceptions to the rule. Liberals want a strong central government to dictate to all 50 states what the policies will be. You will not hear them argue for introducing scientific inquiry into policy making because then they'd have to admit the benefits of federalism.

Another way science can influence policy is when scientific results are considered during policy making. The reasoning is obvious. Maybe it's too obvious and that's the problem. For instance, if we spend millions of dollars for scientists to determine that AIDS is caused by a virus, clearly Congress should consider those results so they don't fight AIDS by funding a national antibiotics campaign. Anyone can see the benefit there. Anyone can take the stance of moral superiority on the issue. But those kinds of issues are often hijacked with ulterior motives. I've already shown that the March on Science is more about social & political issues than science or education. The ulterior motive in this case is promoting a social agenda, as well as finding any excuse to take action against Trump. Is it not remarkable that following Trump's inauguration a women's march was planned within a week and a science march within a month, when we had nothing similar during eight years of Obama? What is more likely, that the marches just happened to occur starting immediately with Trump's ascendancy, or that planner's have co-opted women's and education issues as a thinly veiled excuse for anti-Trump political action?

Another reason to be skeptical of their promotion of science to influence policy is the specific policies at play. While not mentioned, it should be obvious to anyone that the major issue at hand here is climate change. I do have to say that the organizers display great discipline in not naming climate change or other issues specifically. That is because climate change is a charged political issue, and they are trying to maintain a shroud of non-political intent.
Prediction: as the march segues from abstract concept to concrete event we'll see climate change become a dominant issue of the participants
What organizers are advocating for is not the promotion just of hard scientific results, but of a scientific consensus, climate change being the major example. What they are advocating is for scientific conclusions to have greater weight in policy making, but only when it fits their liberal agenda. Climate change is promoted because it complements the political narrative that Western culture is the primary evil in the world. In fact it so closely fits the narrative that we've now seen 3 scandals where fraudulent science was promoted for the purpose of supporting the preferred conclusion. What of other scientific results? Will they also demand that scientific studies of race-IQ correlations be considered when making immigration policy? They'd scream racism from the rooftops faster than you could say "statistically significant."

If the organizers are truly passionate about science, then they should incorporate the scientific process themselves. Hold marches in some cities, but not in others. Make relevant measurements of scientific literacy and achievement in those cities. Determine if marches for science cause those measurements to increase. By doing so they would not only be engaging in science themselves, but also publicly demonstrating the scientific process in action. But then they'd have to accept the risk of having to acknowledge the actual effects of the marches.

Monday, March 13, 2017

March for Science

Which of the following is the best definition for science?
  1. A process for determining objective truth
  2. Learning or contributing to a field of study
  3. A passion or a virtue
  4. Policy advocacy
  5. A group of people that needs more funding
A March for Science is being planned to take place next month in Washington D.C. and some other cities. Which definitions of science are they using? In the spirit of science, we'll investigate in a quasi-scientific manner.

Question:

Which definition of science is the March for Science promoting?

Hypothesis

The marches are primarily about virtue signaling, social / political advocacy, and funding demands. Improving scientific literacy and incorporating the scientific process into public discourse and policy making are secondary considerations, at best.

Approach

Let's use their own promotional verbiage as our source of evidence. Each time their language seems to promote one of the definitions of science, we'll give it a point, and add up the points at the end. We'll map the following types of verbiage to relevant definitions for science:
  1. Promoting use and literacy of the scientific process
  2. Promoting general learning or education
  3. Virtue signaling, appeals to emotion, or promoting a political agenda unrelated to objective scientific inquiry
  4. Promoting policy or influence on policy
  5. Advocating for increased benefits to a particular group

Evidence

First looking at the homepage for the march.
The March for Science demonstrates our passion for science and sounds a call to support and safeguard the scientific community. Recent policy changes have caused heightened worry among scientists.
Points: 3, 4, & 5
We come from all races, all religions, all gender identities, all sexual orientations, all abilities, all socioeconomic backgrounds, all political perspectives, and all nationalities. Our diversity is our greatest strength.
This is just standard liberal rhetoric. Diversity is an orthogonal issue to scientific progress. Points: 4
The mischaracterization of science as a partisan issue, which has given policymakers permission to reject overwhelming evidence, is a critical and urgent matter.
Points: 4
What unites us is a love of science
Points: 3
Science is often an arduous process
A reference to the scientific process!! Points: 1 :)
Our plans for policy change and community outreach will start with Marches for Science world-wide and a teach-in at the National Mall.
Points: 2

Moving on to the Our Mission section.
The March for Science champions robustly funded and publicly communicated science as a pillar of human freedom and prosperity.
Points: 5
[We call for] policy makers to enact evidence based policies in the public interest.
This is not a plea for introducing science into policy making but introducing conclusions of the scientific community into policy making. Points: 4
New policies threaten to further restrict scientists’ ability to research and communicate their findings.
Points: 4, 5
At its core, science is a tool for seeking answers.  It can and should influence policy and guide our long-term decision-making.
Points: 1,4
... a small step in the process toward encouraging the application of science in policy.
So the scientific process in this context is the process towards achieving the preferred public policy. Points: 4
The best way to ensure science will influence policy is to encourage people to appreciate and engage with science. That can only happen through education, communication, and ties of mutual respect between scientists and their communities.
Points: 2, 4

Moving on to the Principles and Goals section.
Scientists work to build a better understanding of the world around us. Science is a process, not a product -- a tool of discovery that allows us to constantly expand and revise our knowledge of the universe. In doing so, science serves the interests of all humans, not just those in power.  We recognize that inclusion, diversity, equity, and accessibility in science are critical to ensure that science reaches its potential to serve all communities. We must protect the rights of every person to engage with, learn from, and help shape science, free from manipulation by special interests. 
Points: 1,  3
Political decision-making that impacts the lives of Americans and the world at large should make use of peer-reviewed evidence and scientific consensus.
Points: 4
We support science education that teaches children and adults to think critically, ask questions, and evaluate truth based on the weight of evidence. Science is not a field that should be understood only by a small few -- every person, from every background, deserves an education that encourages scientific learning alongside the arts and humanities.  Science works best when scientists come from diverse perspectives, and we must work to encourage and support a new generation of scientists that reflects that.
 Points: 1, 3
Our scientific community is best served by including voices and contributions from people of all identities and backgrounds...
 Points: 3
De-funding and hiring freezes in the sciences are against any country’s best interests. We believe that the federal budget should reflect the powerful and vital role that science plays in supporting our democracy. We advocate federal funding in support of research, scientific hiring, and agency application of science to management. This funding cannot be limited to a few fields or specific demographics -- scientific support must be inclusive of diverse disciplines and communities.
Points: 3, 5
Science is first and foremost a human process -- it is conducted, applied, and supported by a diverse body of people. Scientific inquiry is not an abstract process that happens independent of culture and community. It is an enterprise carried out by people who seek to expand our knowledge of the world in the hope of building a better, more informed society.  Our wealth of personal experiences and perspectives is our greatest strength. In putting the people who do science at the forefront of this discussion, we can show that scientists come from all cultural backgrounds, belief systems, orientations, genders, and abilities.
Points: 3
We strive to break down barriers in our own community...we voice our support for science and its benefits to be freely available to people of all countries and backgrounds.
Points: 3
We pledge to speak up for [scientists] when they are silenced, to protect them when they are threatened and to provide them with support when they feel they can no longer serve their institutions.
Points: 5

The section called Diversity Principles includes several paragraphs about diversity. In order to not heavily skew the results by counting each instance or paragraph as a separate point (as has been done so far) we'll just analyze the actions steps at the bottom.
  1. We commit to educating ourselves and others about the issues of inclusion, diversity, equity, and accessibility in science.
  2. We support and encourage the challenging conversations that follow.
  3. We pledge to amplify the work of underrepresented scientists and to address concerns and critiques as we work together to make scientific spaces more equitable.
  4. We stand behind our policies on accessibility, harassment, and nonviolence.
  5. We advocate for the policies enabling equal access to science education, careers in science, and the benefits of science.
Points: 3, 3, 3

From the section After the March.
We believe science education and activism is the key to influencing policy change.
Points: 4

Analysis

The tally results are as follows.

Promoting use and literacy of the scientific process: 3

Promoting general learning or education: 2

Virtue signaling, appeals to emotion, or promoting a political agenda unrelated to objective scientific inquiry: 11

Promoting policy: 9

Advocating for increased benefits to a particular group: 5

The promoters use language to describe science as a method for discovering truth 3 times. They used language promoting general education, virtues (liberal virtues in particular), policy advocacy, and benefits to the scientific community a total of 27 times, even after minimizing the virtue promotions of the Diversity Principles section.

The conclusion is that the hypothesis seems to be confirmed. Promoting science as a process of truth finding is much lower than other considerations. More references are made to virtues of the left, such as diversity, than any other category.

Some people believe the March for Science is mostly about promoting a social and political agenda. The defenders of the march would, one can assume, claim the march is honest advocacy for science. An analysis of the organizers' own promotional material does not support that defense. They reference social values 4 times as often as scientific values, and that is after I ignored quite a few of the former in the tallies. I suspect that a word count analysis would indicate an even greater discrepancy.

Note that the approach is not purely scientific. For one, it is not an objective inquiry. We cannot prove the intentions of the organizers, only do our best to provide compelling arguments. And this analysis is just an argument: a claim backed by evidence. To be a scientific fact would require the use of reproducible experimentation. Performing a study does not necessarily equate to engaging in science.

One might take some issue with counting the reference to policy-making since it is stated as the main objective of the marches. Such a stance does not change the overall conclusions of the numerical analysis, and confesses that the march is misnamed. If that were the case, it should be called March for Promoting the Preferred Policies of the Scientific Community.

Wednesday, March 1, 2017

Bill Nye the Scientism Guy

Billy Nye was on the Tucker Carlson show last night.



In previous posts, such as Scott Adams: The Climate Science Debate Illusion, John Oliver is a Moron: John Oliver is a Moron, and Climate Change Science: So Convincing It's Unreal, I've made the following determinations surrounding the climate change debate.
  1. Most climate-change advocates can't even state basic evidence to support their conclusions.
  2. A consensus of the scientific community does not constitute scientific fact.
  3. Climate study is not truly a science.
  4. The prediction of a model is not a fact.
  5. Climate researchers have now 3 times been caught conspiring to produce fraudulent results to support the warming conclusion.
  6. Scientism is a belief system similar to religion, as opposed to science, which is a process for discerning objective truth.
Many of these examples are on full display in Tucker's interview. Bill Nye comes on to talk about the cognitive dissonance of climate skeptics. He doesn't even want to really talk about the science, as it is "settled". Note the meaning of the phrase cognitive dissonance. It is the state of holding two or more contradictory beliefs. It also implies some level of discomfort with the condition. One is troubled by the contradiction, perhaps at a subconscious level. The discomfort marks the difference of cognitive dissonance with Orwellian doublethink, which can be thought of as an immunity to cognitive dissonance. Those who exhibit the Oliver Effect are also immune, because they are not knowledgeable enough to even comprehend the contradictions of their beliefs.

So in the case of the climate skeptic, what is the cognitive dissonance? According to Nye, the contradictory beliefs are something like this.
  • Climate change is a fact because of the scientific consensus.
  • Climate skeptics are skeptical about climate change.
That is not cognitive dissonance. That is just being skeptical. Think about it. Nye went on the air with the sole intention of talking about cognitive dissonance, and he doesn't even know what it means. He thinks cognitive dissonance means not believing something you should believe. It's a slightly more refined version of the liberal tendency to call everyone who disagrees with them a racist. Everyone who disagrees with me has cognitive dissonance. The man really doesn't seem to know what he's talking about. I wish Tucker would have pushed him on that. 

Tucker did push him hard on point #1 from up above, that climate-change proponents can't state basic evidence to support their claims. He really drills to the heart of the matter. To what degree are humans impacting the climate? What would the climate look like if humans didn't generate CO2? This is the fundamental question of climate change, is it not? Nye said the science was settled, but he can't provide the answer. He should be able to, if he's correct. It would be like going on the air to say that drugs raise crime rates, that all who disagree have cognitive dissonance, and then not even know what percentage of crimes are drug-related. Except it's even worse than that. The drug crime percentage is a knowable statistic. It would be possible to be correct about the causation and not know the statistic, just irresponsible. But in this case it's impossible to know precisely what the climate would look like without human input, just like it's impossible to know if it will rain two months from next Tuesday.

Nye either doesn't understand the concept, or he does but he knows if he admits it he will invalidate the entire premise that there is no room for skepticism when it comes to climate change. His evidence is always in the form of a conclusion. Grapes growing in England is his evidence. But that doesn't say anything about the role carbon dioxide has played. Similarly, he talks about rate increases or coastal cities threatened if sea levels rise. None of this addresses the question. That he can't provide basic evidence for his own beliefs is pretty bad.

It gets even worse. Nye does finally field an answer. He says that without manmade effects, the climate today would be the same as around 1750. After stating that the climate naturally changes, he goes on to assert that without human activities, the climate would not have changed in almost 300 years. That, my friends, is cognitive dissonance.

Monday, February 13, 2017

John Oliver is a Moron: John Oliver is a Moron

John Oliver is a Moron

Tenet 1: John Oliver is a Moron
Tenet 2: John Oliver is wrong on virtually every subject.
Tenet 3: If you find yourself agreeing with John Oliver, you are probably wrong.

John Oliver is a Moron

My apologies for the uncreative title, subtitle, and section headings, but sometimes these things just write themselves. Here's a John Oliver meme I recently encountered which reminded me of my long-held belief that John Oliver is a moron. (Apologies to all morons out there of the more benign variety).

John Oliver is a Moron
John Oliver is a Moron
Here we see Oliver stumble gracelessly into the dual subjects of climate change and public opinion. First we are told that the opinions of 25% of the population are simply irrelevant. Trenchant commentary if he was talking about a country that is not a democracy. Looking at our handy list of dictators and focusing on the Americas, that would limit him to Cuba (whom he defends) and Venezuela (whom he doesn't defend yet can't bring himself to properly criticize either). In those countries, and many of the other dictatorships throughout the world, popular opinion is very unimportant. However the United States is governed by a democracy (link provided for John Oliver). Under a democracy policy decisions are ostensibly made with large input from the governed citizens. Thus 25% of the population doubting climate change does in fact matter. It matters whether you agree or not, because those people have input into policy making. Granted it might be true that the US is not in fact all that democratic and people don't actually have that much input in policy. Or it might be the case the democracy is an institution doomed to failure because people on the whole are not rational. But Oliver is not making commentary on the principles of democracy: he is just ridiculing rubes for chuckles.

John Oliver is a Moron

Second, you have to love this sentence:
You don't need people's opinions on a fact.
And this is where we really dive into the depths of his moronity, or perhaps just the shallowness of his understanding of the domain in which is he is ridiculing people for their beliefs. (Aside: I've still never had a debate with one of these climate change fanatics who could share even basic details about the climate science they're so sure of.) So why is it that Oliver can be so sure climate change is a "fact"? What they will always respond with is: the scientific consensus. Yes the consensus, or the opinions of experts, is all the proof you need. So Oliver's stance on climate change is driven by the two following premises.
  1. You don't need people's opinions on a fact.
  2. Climate change is a fact because of people's opinions.
The only thing proven here is that Oliver is highly immune to cognitive dissonance, drawn from the observation that his head has not exploded (unfortunately). Although another explanation is that he has so little intellectual curiosity that he doesn't realize that consensus is the key argument supporting his assertion that "climate change is a fact". This kind of protection from the trivial nuances of the domain should be generally true in any field of knowledge. We shall henceforth refer to it as the Oliver Effect: when one's understanding of a subject is so shallow that the fundamental contradictions of their opinions on that subject are hidden from them. But this is just what we all know colloquially as "being a moron."

He lists a number of facts to compare to. Let's see if we can prove those things.
Which number is bigger, 5 or 15?
You can't really prove this as it is practically axiomatic.
Are there owls or hats?
Pretty easy to prove by providing an example of either.

Climate change cannot be similarly proved! For reasons I previously explained, we can't actually prove anything about a theory given a single chaotic instance of the phenomenon in action. We can't prove it won't rain tomorrow. We've all seen downpours on days forecasted to have 0% chance of rain. That 15 is larger than 5 is a fact. That owls exist is a fact. That it will rain tomorrow is a model-driven probability, not a fact. "Climate change" is not a fact, or even a statement. Scientific fact requires reproducible experimentation. Blind faith in the academy is exactly what science is designed to avoid.

John Oliver is a Moron

In conclusion, with one bumbling statement Oliver has negated the fundamental bases of both democracy and scientific inquiry in his zeal to paint other people as morons so as to take some pressure off of himself. He's like the kid in class who couldn't read well so he made fun of the teacher's shirt to make everyone else laugh. Granted he is funny. So laugh at him, not with him. And for the love of god please don't be making political or scientific opinions based on the quips of a comedian so lacking in knowledge that the phrase "the Oliver Effect" was named after him. 😄

Monday, February 6, 2017

Climate Change Science: So Convincing It's Unreal

My views on climate change have been influenced by Christopher Monckton, who does not take the stance of refuting overall climate change or even of global warming, but of pointing out the flaws of the mainstream "consensus". He is not a climate change denier, as they like to say, but certainly a climate hype denier.

One of the positions put forth by Monckton is that not only are measurements of warming falling significantly short of predictions (and he takes some issues with the measurements themselves) but that there has been an 18-year pause in measured warming. Dubbed the Global Warming Hiatus, it has been attributed by many as the result of a particular faulty data set. The hiatus really came under scrutiny with a recent infographic of NOAA data that has been going around on social media showing a very clear pervasive warming trend right up to the current year. This seemed to refute the hiatus. I found myself wondering if Monckton was succumbing to his own biases and cherry-picking his data. It would seem to lower his overall credibility on the issue.

Now a climate scientist is blowing the whistle that NOAA has been manipulating it's results. The organization was under great pressure to deliver results that underscored the case for dramatic global warming, and to do so before the Paris climate conventions of 2015. (You know the one where all the Hollywood liberals flew private jets across the ocean so they could lecture about carbon emissions.) Does this vindicate Monckton? Well it doesn't prove he doesn't cherry pick data. But when the evidence used to discredit someone is shown to be fraudulent, well there is certainly some level of vindication to the accused. Further you can't prove someone doesn't cherry pick their data, although you can provide strong evidence that they do.

At a larger scope, this serves to invalidate all results that have come for the NOAA for some time. We know that (1) pressure exists in their organization to prefer certain results, and (2) they have caved to that pressure at least once. When a judge is shown to be similarly biased all their relevant rulings are thrown out, and this should be no different. This is a massive blow to climate change advocates, and a major boon to the skeptics. The blow is much greater to their organization and the political causes than the data would have been a benefit. And a large benefit it was, as even I was questioning the skeptics and I'm very skeptical about the climate change situation.

This is not the first climate scandal of recent times. (Witness Climategates 1 & 2). The biggest complaint we on the right have is not with science, as alleged by the left, but with the scientists. We don't believe they are doing purely objective science. The left invariably responds by reminding us about the vast consensus of climate scientists that proves we are wrong. But does this not cut to the core of scientific inquiry? "Don't trust me, observe for yourself.  My results are reproducible," says every true scientist everywhere. "Consensus" is not a scientific argument. "You're anti-science" isn't even an argument at all. If scientific inquiry meant believing what the academy told us was true, then we'd still be stuck at a heliocentric view of the cosmos.

We allege that there is strong bias within the climate research community. Not just of the researchers themselves (there is strong selection pressure within academia for liberal viewpoints) but more importantly, of the funding of the research. Most research is funded by the federal government. We're told we're being naive and just grasping at straws to invalidate conclusions that contradict our political stances. And yet we now have 3 scandals in recent times that all point to manipulation of research towards the warming conclusion being advocated by the left. Once should have been evidence enough; three indicates an epidemic of political bias in the supposedly sober and impartial field of climate research. At this point it is not unreasonable to question all research whose conclusions support the so-called scientific consensus.

It's Not Even Science

Just a reminder that climate science is not really science. Science consists of four steps.
Model → Prediction → Test → Analysis
The model is our representation of reality. We make predictions within the model, we perform tests in the real world, and we use the results to analyze how well our model corresponds to reality.

In climate change there is no reality to test against. All we have are computer simulations and other models. The climate change predictions are not being made against the real world, but against other models, which are prone to the biases of the implementer. The most notorious example of this was the hockey stick controversy, where plugging in the real-world data yielded such a sharp rise in the rate of global warming that it was said to resemble a hockey stick. The controversy was that any data input to the model yielded a similar result. It would be like a Wall Street broker relying on modeling data that always predicted a bear market. Such a model would not last real-world scrutiny for very long. But climate research is heavily insulated from real-world scrutiny.

Some predictions actually are tested against the actual climate, but we need to be very careful here. Climate is a chaotic system. We can't predict how it will act at any given time, only give probabilities for it. This is no different than standard weather forecasts. If they call for rain tomorrow and it's sunny, it doesn't invalidate meteorology. If we look at large numbers of forecasts / outcomes we'll see they tend to get it right. With the climate we don't have the same advantage. We only have one global climate, and it varies on processes that can take millennia to cycle through.

If a field makes predictions that can't be tested against the real world, is it really a science? Perhaps we should call it climate studies instead. Then what of their practitioners? Are they really scientists? They may be smart and very technically capable people, but I don't see how we can give the label scientist to someone who does not fully engage in the scientific process.

If anyone calls you a science denier for being a climate changed skeptic, the best response is to the effect of: I'm a science advocate which is why I questions outcomes from the field of Climate Studies when they've been repeatedly shown to be politically biased to the point of outright fraud.