Donald Trump has abandoned his supposed conservative principles to make a pointless and offensive attack on a segment of American citizens. He has decided to use his executive power to tell people how they should live, how they should feel, and how they should identify themselves. The most cherished conservative value is freedom from government tyranny, yet not the government is telling the transgendered that they can no longer engage in their right to military service.
The decision violates Christian norms as well. Did Jesus say that trannies shouldn't serve in the military? No. Well really the early Christian doctrine was that no one should serve in the military, one of the major reasons they were so despised by the Romans, but they didn't single out any of the 72 genders in their opposition to martial practices. So Trump's ejection of the gender-atypical is not just anti-libertarian, it is anti-Christian as well.
Finally, Trump's decision violates free-market economic principles. Because the transgendered are oppressed in the marketplace, they are more willing to accept difficult, lower-paying jobs, like enlisted military service. By rejecting these applicants, the President is effectively instilling a minimum wage on military service, thus he is distorting the free market and causing a higher burden on taxpayers.
This decisions stinks. It fails the American ideals of personal liberty and limited government, it fails the Christian ethos of universal equality, and it fails free-market economic principles.
[Except to see some drivel like this being pushed out by the National Review and other pseudo-conservative outlets. McCain, who is only ever in the news for bashing Republicans, is in the news for opposing the tranny ban. Some things are just too predictable to even be amusing.]
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 26, 2017
Tuesday, July 25, 2017
Distortions in the Financial and Political Markets
Financial Markets
If you're a regular to this blog, or to some of the other blogs in the sidebar like oftwominds, then you understand that our financial system is marred by massive market distortions. The market is supposed to work as an information-processing entity that rewards smart enterprises with capital, and smart investors with profits. The investor analyzes companies and decides which, if any, he wants to fund.In reality, things don't quite work that way. Most people invest through proxy. They give their money to a fund manager who does the legwork of poring through financial data for a multitude of ventures, trying to find those most likely to give the best return. Thus, the valuations of the various companies relative to each other have some basis in reality. But the market overall, that's another picture. Aunt Betty doesn't allocate money to the stock market based on the aggregate financial data available to her. She probably sends a fixed amount. For the vast majority of investors, the amount of money they send to market is determined by (a) their pension program, which they have no control over, (b) their 401(k) policy (most people just put in whatever their employer will match), or (c) the recommendation of a financial adviser. (I'll save you the fee; they recommend 15%.)
Most people don't invest in companies; they bet on the market. For those who do trade their own stocks, mostly they buy index funds when they see a bull market, and sell when they see a bear. [Some buy individual stocks, although not always on the best information. Aunt Betty likes her iPhone, so she buys Apple stock. She doesn't know what dividends are, or why she would want to have those.] The question for the typical investor becomes whether the market will rise or fall. Will people keep pumping money in, or will they get scared and pull out? Company valuations become a minute data point, because the amount of money coming in mostly has to do with the overall health of the economy (or its perceived health) and the monetary policy. The Fed can pump the market by lowering interest rates, or deflate it by raising them. That's a lot of power! No wonder investors watch meetings of the Fed Board in real time. The Fed also owns so many assets, some $5 trillion in toxic assets it acquired from TARP, that it can direct the market at will. They could crash the market tomorrow if they decided to dump everything. So the value of your Google stock next month has more to do with monetary policy than how Google is being run.
The gist of this is the market, previously an engine for efficiently matching investment capital with business enterprises, is now a casino that matches investment capital with monetary policy and the hope that everyone else will keep investing. Think of the difference. In the old system, if you sniffed a sweet investment, you didn't want other people knowing about it. You prefer your investment dollars to be at a premium, thus more valued by the business venture, meaning you might expect better returns, such as higher dividends. None of the FAANG stocks (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google) pay dividends. They don't need to. If you buy them you hope everyone buys them, driving the price up, because that's the only way you're going to make any money off them. The old feedback loop has been dismantled. So when will company financial data feed back into market investment? At the next crash, one presumes. The efficient processing of information is gone. Reality only feeds back into the system in intermittent, jarring, and chaotic events.
Political Markets
There are two major ways to view democracy, and probably lots of minor ways. It's a complicated thing. One way to look at it, as suggested by Jim's Blog, is that democracy is a proxy for war. Instead of drawing up sides and fighting it out on the battlefield, we simply count heads to determine who would have won, and put them in charge. Democracy circumvents the horribly self-destructive process of civil war, and everyone gets to go home to their families. We'll come back to this.
The other way to think of democracy is as a marketplace of ideas. The various entities in the nation use the methods of persuasion at their disposal to influence the populace, then we count heads to see who had the best ideas. This is why we hold our freedoms of speech and of the press in such high regard. Those are not idealistic moral judgments. They are absolutely essential to the efficient flow of information in the marketplace of ideas. Without them the market of democracy is distorted, and doomed to eventual, and painful, market corrections. There are some other requirements. The voting public must be rational and operate in good faith. The government must faithfully execute the decisions of the democratic process.
I'm sure you see where we're going with this. In all critical aspects, our democracy-as-marketplace is seriously distorted. The mainstream media is primarily propaganda, not honest journalism. Other avenues of information sharing are corrupted. Just today Twitter killed another trending hashtag damaging to the Democrats. In this one, a DNC IT staffer, who was fired 6 months ago for obvious fraud and apparent data theft, was still being paid by Debbie Wasserman-Schultz (remember, she was fired from her position as DNC chair after email leaks revealed she was throwing the election for Hillary), and was only fired after he was arrested by the FBI while trying to flee the country! But those hashtags are removed in favor of Russian conspiracy theory nonsense. Clearly the channels of communication are not conducive to pragmatic decision-making by the populace. The public is fed fiction and believe it to be objective truth.
The other aspects are failing as well. The voters need to be rational and acting in good faith. Well half of them believe the Russia conspiracy theories after 13 months with no evidence and not even a description of the alleged crime. It would seem that about half of the electorate does not satisfy the criteria of rational. And a significant number are ideologically opposed to even having a dialog with their opponents whom they see as literally Nazis. So certainly they are not acting in good faith. The other requirement, that the government faithfully abide the decisions of the people, is also violated. Half of the deep state, and nearly all the propaganda machine, are working to reject the president elected by the people. The government frequently ignores the will of the people, or adopts their preferred policies but does not act on them. Nearly everyone, from both aisles, opposed the Wall Street bailouts, and they still happened under presidents from both parties. A decade ago their was bi-partisan legislation passed to build a border wall. It never materialized. Everyone wanted banksters to be prosecuted for fraud that contributed to the 2008 financial crisis. Not one person, not even a patsy, saw jail time. And now, the Republicans own the whole federal government, largely by promising to repeal Obamacare, yet we are seeing that no meaningful repeal will happen, and maybe not even a nominal repeal.
All the requirements for an efficient democratic market are, well, requirements. The loss of one can destroy everything. All are failing today. The prognosis for a democratic collapse is nearly the same as that for a financial crash. It's not a matter of if, but when.
Let's go back to the other perspective of democracy for a quick second; that democracy is a proxy for civil war, and awards those who would have won on the battlefield. The key requirement for this arrangement to endure is that the people who would have won the war tend to win the elections. At the very least they should not be treated as vanquished chattel. Otherwise, at some point, the would-be warriors start to think, "Gee, maybe we'd get a better deal if we just took this all over by force." Think of our situation now. The military, the police, and nearly all men who own firearms are Trump supporters. Yet he is currently under soft coup by the party populated by gender-fluid feminists and limp-wristed manlets, who want to take all the money they can grab from the former group. They can hardly be reasoned with, and eventually the right wing will realize that they can only defend themselves by physical force, not by engaging in the defunct marketplace of ideas.
The financial and democratic feedback loops in this country are wildly dysfunctional. Remember, the number one rule of economics is the markets always correct. Reality denial is not a sustainable condition. The only practical advice here is to become antifragile. Expect that there will be abrupt and chaotic market corrections in our future. If you don't yet know how you would benefit in those kinds of scenarios, then you are certainly fragile to the inevitable.
Thursday, May 4, 2017
Flashback to the 2016 Democratic Campaign
As a reminder of what the Democratic campaign against Donald Trump looked like, here is a message Elizabeth Warren posted on Facebook a year ago today.
While we're having problems now with Trump seeming to flake on his campaign promises, let's never forget why he won the election. Trump was out there talking about major policy issues: immigration, trade, national security. The Democrats were name-calling. Look at all the insults this US Senator hurled in a brief and public post.
- racism
- sexism
- xenophobia
- KKK
- incites supporters to violence
- praises Putin
- authoritarian
- dictator
- attacks
- puts our servicemembers at risk
- cheerleads illegal torture
- a collection of charlatans
- contradictory
- nonsensical
- incoherent
- truly bizarre
- narcissism
- divisiveness
- toxic stew of hatred and insecurity
223 words written, and 20% of them are insults. The rest serve merely as scaffolding, a place to hang the insults like little ornaments of angst. They are just overhead. The only item in the whole post that communicated any information was the phrase "toxic stew of hatred and insecurity," which seems to be a projection of Senator Warren's own psychological condition. Other than that, there is nothing of substance to be found in this rant. Remember, we were told constantly that Trump was the vacuous candidate, the know-nothing who would disgrace our political system. And yet this sitting senator, one of the leading Democrats in the country, could do no better than string a series of insults together.
The American public picked up on this, to some extent. Enough to give Trump a strong electoral victory, at least. And if in the next three years the Democrats can't find someone to do any better than just string insults together, a task for which most playground children are qualified, then I wouldn't suppose 2020 will be very pleasant for them, whether or not Trump abandons his base.
Monday, March 20, 2017
Republican Contradictions
The great challenge of Trump's presidency is quickly approaching. It is not building The Wall, or repealing Obamacare, or fighting the various establishment power blocks. It is navigating the debt ceiling. On one hand it shouldn't be a big deal. It was only an issue under Obama because Republicans in Congress fought him over it. Trump has both houses of Congress, so one would think that Republicans would be able to fund their own budget. To fail to do so seems extraordinarily self-defeating. But it is logical as it only exposes some core contradictions within the party.
Foremost, Republicans are the party of fiscal responsibility, yet they don't tend to be very fiscally responsible, not in Washington at least. That's a pretty big contradiction, and a lack of integrity. A general distrust of Republican integrity is what allowed for the rise of Trump to begin with. Trump himself has railed against Obama's doubling of the national debt, yet is proposing big spending coupled with big tax cuts. He vows he can do those things and avoid a spiraling debt situation because his leadership will drive a resurgent economy. It not wise to outright dismiss Trump, the exemplar of achievement despite all odds, but it all does sound something like a fairy tale.
Another contradiction is that the Republicans have unified power in Washington, but are not that unified. Congressional leaders like McCain and Ryan have betrayed Trump at every opportunity it was politically expedient to do so. Others are not actually conservative, and won't vote to take away any federal benefit that might cause them political harm. So we have a Congress that says it's conservative and fiscally responsible, but isn't; who wants to fund it's own agenda but is afraid to lose face for not backing the claimed fiscal responsibility it doesn't really have; and who should do so any way to support the Republican president whom they also frequently betray. That's a lot of contradictions. And it makes it impossible to predict anything.
If the Republicans can overcome their own self-contradictions, and it turns out that Trump is an excellent president except that his policy program tends to push the federal government even closer to bankrupty, well then maybe that would make him a perfect president.
Foremost, Republicans are the party of fiscal responsibility, yet they don't tend to be very fiscally responsible, not in Washington at least. That's a pretty big contradiction, and a lack of integrity. A general distrust of Republican integrity is what allowed for the rise of Trump to begin with. Trump himself has railed against Obama's doubling of the national debt, yet is proposing big spending coupled with big tax cuts. He vows he can do those things and avoid a spiraling debt situation because his leadership will drive a resurgent economy. It not wise to outright dismiss Trump, the exemplar of achievement despite all odds, but it all does sound something like a fairy tale.
Another contradiction is that the Republicans have unified power in Washington, but are not that unified. Congressional leaders like McCain and Ryan have betrayed Trump at every opportunity it was politically expedient to do so. Others are not actually conservative, and won't vote to take away any federal benefit that might cause them political harm. So we have a Congress that says it's conservative and fiscally responsible, but isn't; who wants to fund it's own agenda but is afraid to lose face for not backing the claimed fiscal responsibility it doesn't really have; and who should do so any way to support the Republican president whom they also frequently betray. That's a lot of contradictions. And it makes it impossible to predict anything.
If the Republicans can overcome their own self-contradictions, and it turns out that Trump is an excellent president except that his policy program tends to push the federal government even closer to bankrupty, well then maybe that would make him a perfect president.
Wednesday, March 15, 2017
Equality as a Gauge for Political Stance
Equality and Other Founding Myths showed that many of the enshrined American values promoted today weren't shared by the founders, at least not in their present form. It showed a progression of the ideal of equality from past to present. In the Declaration of Independence equality was meant as a rebuke to the king of England. "All men are created equal" was a dismissal of the monarchical claim of a divine right to rule. In the current era, many interpret equality as "equal social and economic outcomes."
Tenet: one's political stance can be approximated by their interpretation of equality as a Constitutional right.There are roughly four different interpretations of equality.
- Rejection of the divine right to rule
- Equality under the law
- Equal opportunity
- Equal outcomes
Equal outcomes is the stance of the left. They assert that any observed inequality is the result of foul play and oppression. Equal opportunity is the position of classical liberals, moderate conservatives, and libertarians and asserts one's status at birth should not dictate their status later in life. Equality under the law is the typical definition of equality. Those who advocate for equality under the law but not equal opportunity populate the hard right. Those who do not even advocate for equality under the law are rare. White supremacists would probably fall into that group, but not all. For instance the KKK are widely labeled as white supremacist but they advocate a position of separate but equal, just as some black nationalists have. While it is rare, I predict we'll see an increase in rejection of legal equality as the multicultural nation fractures along ethic fault lines. I suspect we will see a rise in white supremacy in reaction to the anti-white hatred of the left, in the same way we saw the rise of Trump caused by the media's anti-Trump hysteria. They have a tendency of creating the very thing they are most afraid of.
The left-right boundary today is between equality stages 3 and 4. Most classical liberals vote Republican, as do libertarians. Not many Democrats reject equality of outcomes, and the party platform codifies widespread & institutional oppression as a core party belief. Equality of opportunity means public education, public infrastructure, and laws encouraging meritocracy. Equality of outcomes means redistribution of wealth, a highly progressive tax scheme, and preferential access to jobs & education for the underperforming demographics.
A question that arises is, if equal outcomes is adopted as the norm, where will the left/right divide then be? Will everyone be on the right side of the divide? Such a situation would mean each person gets the same outcome no matter their productivity. It is definitively communism. How does one go left from communism? Can we further liberalize the concept of equality?
Such a description reads like dystopian fiction, but it is the final logical step of the increasingly liberal definition of equality. Fortunately, we aren't likely to ever see such a reality because the society will fail in Stage 4 of Equality, as it always has.
A question that arises is, if equal outcomes is adopted as the norm, where will the left/right divide then be? Will everyone be on the right side of the divide? Such a situation would mean each person gets the same outcome no matter their productivity. It is definitively communism. How does one go left from communism? Can we further liberalize the concept of equality?
Tenet: the final liberalization of equality is "equality of being."The final step of equality is biological and cognitive equality. We imagine eugenics being used to create superior men, but in Stage 5 of Equality eugenics will be applied to promote uniformity of the gene pool. No one too tall or too short; no one too smart or too dumb. Pregnancy will be highly regulated, with in utero fertilization being the norm, and any natural pregnancies showing outlying genetic profiles will be subject to abortion. In development, children with natural talents will be subdued, either psychologically or chemically. Society will strictly enforce conformity, and citizens will strive to downplay their status, wealth, or abilities at all cost.
Such a description reads like dystopian fiction, but it is the final logical step of the increasingly liberal definition of equality. Fortunately, we aren't likely to ever see such a reality because the society will fail in Stage 4 of Equality, as it always has.
Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Discussion of March for Science Analysis
In March for Science I analyzed the march organizers' own promotional materials to determine what interpretations of science they are predominately marching for. One conclusion was that the second highest motivation was influencing policy with science. That shouldn't be surprising as a March on Washington is quite likely to be about influencing policy. Influencing policy with science sounds like a no-brainer, but what are they really advocating for? There are different ways to look at influencing policy with science.
The truest interpretation of science is as a process. Not as a body of knowledge, or a community, or a philosophy or belief system, but as a method used to strain objective truth from the murky soup of human observations and beliefs. The most straightforward influence of science on policy making is to incorporate scientific inquiry into the political process. It is the scam of the modern era that our allegedly scientific society does not directly apply science to the task of policy making. How can we truly know the effects of policy in highly complex fields like healthcare if we aren't experimenting and measuring results? There is a single informal method of A/B testing in policy, which was granted to us by the Founding Fathers in the form of federalism. States' rights allow for the simultaneous implementation of various policy approaches that can be analyzed for effectiveness. Yet liberals who are organizing the march have very little interest in states' rights, except for when they provide immediate and narrowly scoped support to causes such as marijuana legalization and gay marriage. But those are exceptions to the rule. Liberals want a strong central government to dictate to all 50 states what the policies will be. You will not hear them argue for introducing scientific inquiry into policy making because then they'd have to admit the benefits of federalism.
Another way science can influence policy is when scientific results are considered during policy making. The reasoning is obvious. Maybe it's too obvious and that's the problem. For instance, if we spend millions of dollars for scientists to determine that AIDS is caused by a virus, clearly Congress should consider those results so they don't fight AIDS by funding a national antibiotics campaign. Anyone can see the benefit there. Anyone can take the stance of moral superiority on the issue. But those kinds of issues are often hijacked with ulterior motives. I've already shown that the March on Science is more about social & political issues than science or education. The ulterior motive in this case is promoting a social agenda, as well as finding any excuse to take action against Trump. Is it not remarkable that following Trump's inauguration a women's march was planned within a week and a science march within a month, when we had nothing similar during eight years of Obama? What is more likely, that the marches just happened to occur starting immediately with Trump's ascendancy, or that planner's have co-opted women's and education issues as a thinly veiled excuse for anti-Trump political action?
Another reason to be skeptical of their promotion of science to influence policy is the specific policies at play. While not mentioned, it should be obvious to anyone that the major issue at hand here is climate change. I do have to say that the organizers display great discipline in not naming climate change or other issues specifically. That is because climate change is a charged political issue, and they are trying to maintain a shroud of non-political intent.
If the organizers are truly passionate about science, then they should incorporate the scientific process themselves. Hold marches in some cities, but not in others. Make relevant measurements of scientific literacy and achievement in those cities. Determine if marches for science cause those measurements to increase. By doing so they would not only be engaging in science themselves, but also publicly demonstrating the scientific process in action. But then they'd have to accept the risk of having to acknowledge the actual effects of the marches.
The truest interpretation of science is as a process. Not as a body of knowledge, or a community, or a philosophy or belief system, but as a method used to strain objective truth from the murky soup of human observations and beliefs. The most straightforward influence of science on policy making is to incorporate scientific inquiry into the political process. It is the scam of the modern era that our allegedly scientific society does not directly apply science to the task of policy making. How can we truly know the effects of policy in highly complex fields like healthcare if we aren't experimenting and measuring results? There is a single informal method of A/B testing in policy, which was granted to us by the Founding Fathers in the form of federalism. States' rights allow for the simultaneous implementation of various policy approaches that can be analyzed for effectiveness. Yet liberals who are organizing the march have very little interest in states' rights, except for when they provide immediate and narrowly scoped support to causes such as marijuana legalization and gay marriage. But those are exceptions to the rule. Liberals want a strong central government to dictate to all 50 states what the policies will be. You will not hear them argue for introducing scientific inquiry into policy making because then they'd have to admit the benefits of federalism.
Another way science can influence policy is when scientific results are considered during policy making. The reasoning is obvious. Maybe it's too obvious and that's the problem. For instance, if we spend millions of dollars for scientists to determine that AIDS is caused by a virus, clearly Congress should consider those results so they don't fight AIDS by funding a national antibiotics campaign. Anyone can see the benefit there. Anyone can take the stance of moral superiority on the issue. But those kinds of issues are often hijacked with ulterior motives. I've already shown that the March on Science is more about social & political issues than science or education. The ulterior motive in this case is promoting a social agenda, as well as finding any excuse to take action against Trump. Is it not remarkable that following Trump's inauguration a women's march was planned within a week and a science march within a month, when we had nothing similar during eight years of Obama? What is more likely, that the marches just happened to occur starting immediately with Trump's ascendancy, or that planner's have co-opted women's and education issues as a thinly veiled excuse for anti-Trump political action?
Another reason to be skeptical of their promotion of science to influence policy is the specific policies at play. While not mentioned, it should be obvious to anyone that the major issue at hand here is climate change. I do have to say that the organizers display great discipline in not naming climate change or other issues specifically. That is because climate change is a charged political issue, and they are trying to maintain a shroud of non-political intent.
Prediction: as the march segues from abstract concept to concrete event we'll see climate change become a dominant issue of the participantsWhat organizers are advocating for is not the promotion just of hard scientific results, but of a scientific consensus, climate change being the major example. What they are advocating is for scientific conclusions to have greater weight in policy making, but only when it fits their liberal agenda. Climate change is promoted because it complements the political narrative that Western culture is the primary evil in the world. In fact it so closely fits the narrative that we've now seen 3 scandals where fraudulent science was promoted for the purpose of supporting the preferred conclusion. What of other scientific results? Will they also demand that scientific studies of race-IQ correlations be considered when making immigration policy? They'd scream racism from the rooftops faster than you could say "statistically significant."
If the organizers are truly passionate about science, then they should incorporate the scientific process themselves. Hold marches in some cities, but not in others. Make relevant measurements of scientific literacy and achievement in those cities. Determine if marches for science cause those measurements to increase. By doing so they would not only be engaging in science themselves, but also publicly demonstrating the scientific process in action. But then they'd have to accept the risk of having to acknowledge the actual effects of the marches.
Saturday, March 11, 2017
Why Can't We Be More Like Japan?
Lately liberals are floating this meme around:
Why can't we be more like Japan? Hey, that's something we can all agree on. A few other relevant statistics.
Why can't we be more like Japan? Hey, that's something we can all agree on. A few other relevant statistics.
- Japan is almost completely ethnically homogeneous.
- Japan allows very little immigration.
- Japan has a very strong culture that normalizes modes of behavior.
- Japanese obesity rates are a tenth of those in the US.
- Drug addiction is rare in Japan.
If the question is Why can't we be more like Japan? then many on the far right will agree. I guarantee you every last one would make the trade of state healthcare for strongly enforced national homogeneity and norms of behavior. Do you think liberals ever notice that their models for social democracy are places with strong national identities? (Or were until so recently.)
Friday, March 10, 2017
What Are Liberals So Afraid Of?
In this post, the author tries to make sense of what liberals are afraid of. It's a fair question. They've gone hysterical over Trump's election. They themselves frequently made claims that it was Trump who actually engaged in fear-mongering, but their own language reveal the assertion as mere psychological projection. They routinely told us they feared for the country, for women, for gays, for foreigners, and on and on. Even Obama expressed that fear dominated the left:
I would fear for the future of our country.Much has been written by the media to analyze the alleged fear of the right that drove them to elect Trump, but very little on the manic phobias of the left that drove many to commit themselves to mental institutes on election night and has caused an explosion of therapy cases. If our media was objective and fair this issue would have been well covered. Since it hasn't, bloggers are trying to fill in the gaps. If you boil the linked post down it provides the following 12 hypotheses for the state of widespread liberal fear.
- Liberals are herd animals
- Worries about funding cuts
- All change is scary
- Jewish paranoia
- They're faking it
- The believe they are the underdogs
- They instinctively solve problems with appeasement
- Fear of chaos
- No more handouts
- Fear that they were wrong the whole time
- White supremacy
- War, fight to the death
Some come close, but none address the fundamental fear of liberals. If you are unsure what that fear is, then you aren't reading enough Anonymous Conservative, who has put forth the only hypothesis I know of that accounts for the entirety of liberal / conservative behaviors in a cohesive and logically consistent way. From his theory liberal fear can be summed up very succinctly: they are afraid of direct competition for resources. Let's analyze the 12 fear hypotheses in order, from those closest to the fundamental cause of liberal fear, to the least relevant.
#2, and #9 come closest to the mark. These directly assault the liberal need for resources to be freely supplied to them. Nothing scares a liberal more than funding cuts to programs that provide them with free resources they don't have to acquire through direct market competition.
#1, #6, #11, and #12 drive at the heart of the matter: fear of direct competition. Herd animals don't compete with each other for resources, they move in groups for mutual protections to areas with the most abundant resources. Deportations and race wars elicit fears of competition on a massive scale between ethnic and cultural groups. Nothing could be more unnerving to the liberal. To them no one should have to die just because they are unable to acquire the resources needed for life. Because liberals believe they are naturally disadvantaged to direct competition, they will do anything to avoid such a scenario.
#7 is profoundly true and I would challenge anyone to think of counter examples. Liberals always back down from potential confrontation when they can just throw free resources at the problem. Foreigners illegally cross our borders by the millions and cost the US over $100 billion per year. Just let them stay. Inner city blacks commit violent crimes at many times the background rate. They need more welfare. Americans schools are falling further and further behind in international standards. They just need more funding. Liberals are incapable of contemplating the fundamental causes for any social ill when public money is available.
#10 is indirectly true. They aren't afraid of being wrong in the logical sense. They aren't afraid of being contradicted in the way that intellectual narcissists like Stefan Molyneux are. They're afraid of being wrong in the sense of group consensus. Liberals are desperately afraid of being out-grouped. They cannot survive outside of the co-operative group environment. Banishment is a death sentence. Thus they are afraid of any hint of outgrouping. And this fear is projected in how they attack their opponents. They use labels to outgroup conservatives. By calling conservatives racists and then saying American has no tolerance for racism, they attempt to outgroup. They try to shut down freedoms of speech and assembly. That is, they attack their opponents rights to join in groups. They even swarm the employers of their opponents and get them fired. They use these tactics because they are themselves terrified of being outgrouped or isolated.
#5 is not true. They aren't faking their fear. They are responding to deep psychological urges. They might be attempting to delude others but only because they have already deluded themselves. If they actually understood what was driving their anxiety, they wouldn't be liberals for long, would they? Knowing is half the battle.
#3 and #8 are nearly the same thing. They aren't afraid of change; they're afraid of change that doesn't benefit them or benefits their opponents. They aren't afraid of chaos. They loves chaos if it suits them. Chaos means their opponents can't organize to compete against them. However free-for-all chaos where everyone is in direct competition would be a terrifying thought.
Thursday, March 9, 2017
We've Tried Being Reasonable
The Proposition Nation
America, the proposition nation. Founded on ideas. American society was not to be bound by a divinely anointed monarch, or tribal loyalties, or a heavy-handed authority, but rather by the agreement that natural rights grant each man great freedom to live as he chooses, so long as he doesn't impede the rights of others to do the same. Americanism is not a birthright or a blessing or a victory condition; it is a simple logical and moral agreement.The Founders were all Christians yet they specifically decreed freedom of religion. They were all English-speaking but made no recommendation for language. They were all white but put no Constitutional restriction on demographics, as Mexico does. One wonders if these considerations weren't omitted as a consequence of their absence from the contemporary society. The rich do not worry over money like the poor. The hungry think about food constantly while the well-fed eat when it is convenient. Noble decrees of equality and an appeal to our higher faculties may be easier to make in a ethnically homogeneous society of a relatively high IQ populace bound by a common belief system. Many among us, probably most, do not believe this to be the case. Their conviction is that our multiculturalism drives the reason-based social contract, because we don't have the tribal, religious, or dynastic bindings to rely on. But was that the reality of our founding? They didn't invite the Indians into their new society. Or the Africans. And heavily resisted even non-English speaking Europeans and Catholics. It does seem that man's more primitive instincts towards social organization were overcome in an environment where they were somewhat irrelevant to begin with.
America (or more accurately the West) is so confidant in her citizens' capacity for reason that they were granted universal suffrage, an empowerment of the masses never seen before. Despite some initial limitations set by the Founders, American is a system where every representative, every senator, every governor, every mayor, and every president is chosen by the masses. Surely the contract for the people to chose their government includes the clause that they are, well, reasonable.
To the notion of a society bound by reason, I am a natural proponent. And yet I am abhorred by the results. This is hardly a reasonable society. It is not populated by particularly reasonable people, and does very little to leverage its more rational human assets. We don't organize our society to put the more reasonable people in charge. I encountered this the first time I voted. My ballot included 46 different individual races - and I was from a tiny town and county - plus referendum measures. It quickly became questionable to me how anyone could be qualified to fill out the ballot. Who was I to comment on whether to retain various judges throughout the far-flung state? I considered myself to be more qualified to vote than most, but still not sufficient for the ballot I was provided. I did a fair amount of research on candidates before voting, which is a fair amount more than most I would reckon. How can we be sure the typical American voter is unqualified for the task? Because candidates spend exorbitant sums of money on radio and tv ads. Why? Because the ads successfully influence a significant number of votes. Why are ads successful in influencing a rational person's vote? I'll leave you to make your own conclusion.
Wisdom & Education
In the ancient world wisdom was the highest virtue. Elders were respected; the great minds were highly sough after. Today's world has no interest in wisdom. Technical expertise is highly valued, and credentials, oh do we love our credentials. It seems that credentials are something of a proxy for wisdom. Or at least they once were. At one time a college degree probably did have some correlation with wisdom, because the institutions that granted them were motivated by achieving wisdom. In today's college imparting wisdom is their stated sacred purpose but in practice hardly even an afterthought. Students don't go to college to gain wisdom. They go to gain status. Colleges serve to provide careers to students, academics, and administrators, and recruits for liberal indoctrination. It can't even be decisively claimed that colleges are for acquiring information anymore, as most of it can be found online.The schools don't drive kids towards wisdom. They seek to impart skills. And not just any skills, but skills that can be captured by standardized testing. In the decade and a half since I graduated, my high school has dropped band, chorus, auto shop, ag shop, industrial arts, and, I think, physics. I'm not entirely sure about the last one. On the school's website I can find a 54-page policy handbook and schedules for all the varsity sports, but not a list of courses. Academics are just not a big priority in education these days.
American parents don't drive kids towards wisdom either. Do you hear parents asking themselves if junior will read Rousseau or understand chaos theory? No, parents wonder what occupation their child will hold and brag about their successes. Typically successes are measured in the acquisition of resources (money) or title (status). Thus children are primarily guided towards money & status. The major difference between white suburban childrearing and gangsta rap is that the rappers are more honest about their ambitions.
Caring
Not everyone stives for money & status. Some people reject the rat race or, more often, are rejected by it. Often they are hippies, and they know there is something much more important than petty materialism: caring. Caring is a virtue of course. Caring gives life meaning and is fundamental to Christianity. But it is no substitute for reason. An uncaring civilization can still succeed and provide a nice life for its people (like Germany until so recently) but an unreasonable society will destroy itself or be destroyed, caring or not.
I see on social media the liberal motto it is better to be kind than correct. But those attributes are orthogonal. It's as if saying it's better to be left than purple. One can be kind and correct, or one of them, or neither. Maybe I'm too pedantic when the intended message is clear: it's better to be caring than rational. It seems fitting then that the quip is itself irrational. Better according to what context? Where is it better to be caring than rational? Who says, "you need to be kind and wrong more?"
Caring is seen as enlightenment. And it is! Compare it to the money chasers. They are consumed with acquiring resources, just like every organism on Earth. Even lowly life forms like amoeba and fungi and divorce lawyers spend their time primarily engaged in resource acquisition. If hippies think caring is a higher, more enlightened motive in life I would have to agree with them. Caring is not restricted to humanity. Mammals by definition care for their young. Social animals develop deep attachments to each other. Even crocodiles are said to be make protective mothers. But none are capable of rationale. Caring is a humane trait but rationale is what makes us human. To say it is better to be kind than correct as a life philosophy is practically to renounce one's own humanity.
Media
If future generations will judge us by the fruits of our professional media then we should start destroying the records immediately to save some embarrassment. I cringe thinking our 24/7 news hysteria is constantly being broadcast out to space where it might be received by some intelligent life form. It's no wonder those superior beings choose to remain hidden. Can you imagine how they'd be welcomed here?Alien: we come and peace, and we wish to share our ancient wisdom with you, and guide you to deeper understandings of existence.
CNN reporter: What can you tell us about the Russia-Trump connection?There can be nothing more irrational than making routine logical contradictions with oneself. I point out media absurdity frequently on this blog. It is my top grievance with our society. As long as our established method of public discourse and consensus making is irrational, we can't possibly call ourselves a rational society.
Conclusions
The major point of America is that authority is based on reason and universal egalitarianism. To be sure it was an experiment, and it was not an irrational experiment. The Founders were dedicated to reason themselves and to Enlightenment thought and, in a world where brute strength typically rules, it is truly remarkable what they accomplished. In a rational society experiments are important, but so are results. The results are not looking good. America has been extraordinarily successful and still is, but we're moving in a dangerous direction and very quickly. The major difference between the traditional conservative and the reactionary is that the reactionary doubts the entire premise of the American experiment. Some even doubt the reason-based society altogether and advocate for a return to monarchy! I don't. If you like your reason-based society, and you want to keep your reason-based society, your most immediate task is to realize just how failed the model has become and where we're headed.Wednesday, March 8, 2017
RinoCare: Good News for People Who Like Bad News
Paul Ryan's proposed healthcare bill is out. It's a steaming pile, as you might imagine. It's probably worse even than I expected, and I've already called Ryan out as the biggest traitor in politics ever. Subsidies are still there but renamed. The individual mandate is still there but renamed and penalties offset from the IRS to the insurance companies (a smart political move). It's still a massive entitlement program that requires heavy taxation, heavy redistribution of wealth, conflates healthcare with health insurance, and doesn't address the high prices.
The bill is being dubbed RinoCare, ObamaCareLite, and ObamaCare 2.0, among other names. Some are calling it TrumpCare, but I'm not sure if that's accurate. Trump campaigned on "Repeal & Replace." This is more like "Rename & Modify." Perhaps modify doesn't signify much. No one claimed that Obamacare would never be modified. After the massive premium increases last year Democrats said that everything would be fine as long as Hillary could go in and "tweak" the legislation. Let's call it "Rename & Recess". The Republican Congressmen can shuffle things around, pass a bill that is fundamentally equivalent to Obamacare, and duck out of town before anyone in the media has time to call them racist.
Here are some handy guidelines to tell you how you should feel about this legislation.
- If you're a conservative, you should be outraged in principle, but not in practice. Make any sense? Because conservatives are in principle rooted in traditional cultural values and small government ethos but in practice tend to borrow and spend to grow the size of government. Since the government plans to spend more on healthcare and on the military you should balance out to contentment.
- If you're a liberal, you'll have to wait and see whether or not Trump supports it. Initial reactions indicate he's pushing for it, so I guess you'll need to be against it.
- If you're a libertarian, you're probably a liberal who doesn't like the government telling you what to do. Your biggest gripe should be that the individual mandate wasn't eliminated, just shuffled around.
- If you're a constitutionalist, you should oppose the bill on grounds that the 10th Amendment has not yet been repealed.
- If you're a socialist, you should love the bill because it's a government program doomed to failure that Republicans are calling the "free-market solution" anyway. Patience Iago, PATIENCE! As soon as the whole thing collapses on itself you can scream until your lungs bleed that free-market healthcare solutions don't work.
So what if you're an alt-righter or one of those right-wing neo-reactionaries? (There's a decent chance if you follow this blog). Neo-reactionaries are certainly opposed to this kind of legislation that furthers the scope of national largess. And that's why we should support it.
Let's make an analogy. Look at Sweden. Sweden has hit peak insanity, as best as I can tell. That's not necessarily sober analysis, it may just be a lack of creativity. Just because I can't imagine how they could be much more absurd doesn't mean it isn't possible. The long-term prospects of Sweden as a culture and as a nation seem to depend on whether they can bankrupt themselves before they destroy themselves. Bankruptcy is sometimes all that stops the gambling addict, and so it may be all that ends the dangerous spiral of pathological altruism.
The brave Swedes lead the way, but the US doesn't lag terribly far behind. As far as healthcare goes, the expectation that the federal government should provide healthcare to all citizens has been established. Trump ran to replace Obamacare, not to remove national healthcare. At this point, it's practically semantics. The people demand healthcare, and politicians who refuse will find themselves sitting at home watching with the rest of us. Writing blogs, probably.
A democracy that gives universal suffrage to a generally irresponsible populace is without a doubt embarked on a slow boat to disaster. The normal tendency of inevitable disasters is the sooner the better. The longer the tectonic pressures build, the more catastrophic the inevitable earthquake. The longer the bubble inflates, the harder the crash. If you see the United States as such a disaster set in motion, then your motivations should be (1) to precipitate the collapse as soon as possible, and (2) to have yourself in the best possible position when that time comes. In general, this means to spiral the debt so high that the government is impeded in its functioning and that either default or inflation is inevitable, which would help prevent foreign debt holders from sucking all the remaining wealth out.
On healthcare, if the people demand it, that's what we'll get. So we want the plan that tends to be funded by government debt. Not taxes, and not increasing premiums and others costs. The government is largely responsible for driving up the cost of healthcare to begin with. Now they want to take over the industry entirely. Fine, let's just make sure we aren't the ones getting saddled with the cost, and that it serves our intentions of bankrupting the Fedguv sooner than later.
The brave Swedes lead the way, but the US doesn't lag terribly far behind. As far as healthcare goes, the expectation that the federal government should provide healthcare to all citizens has been established. Trump ran to replace Obamacare, not to remove national healthcare. At this point, it's practically semantics. The people demand healthcare, and politicians who refuse will find themselves sitting at home watching with the rest of us. Writing blogs, probably.
A democracy that gives universal suffrage to a generally irresponsible populace is without a doubt embarked on a slow boat to disaster. The normal tendency of inevitable disasters is the sooner the better. The longer the tectonic pressures build, the more catastrophic the inevitable earthquake. The longer the bubble inflates, the harder the crash. If you see the United States as such a disaster set in motion, then your motivations should be (1) to precipitate the collapse as soon as possible, and (2) to have yourself in the best possible position when that time comes. In general, this means to spiral the debt so high that the government is impeded in its functioning and that either default or inflation is inevitable, which would help prevent foreign debt holders from sucking all the remaining wealth out.
On healthcare, if the people demand it, that's what we'll get. So we want the plan that tends to be funded by government debt. Not taxes, and not increasing premiums and others costs. The government is largely responsible for driving up the cost of healthcare to begin with. Now they want to take over the industry entirely. Fine, let's just make sure we aren't the ones getting saddled with the cost, and that it serves our intentions of bankrupting the Fedguv sooner than later.
Sunday, March 5, 2017
Democrats Face a Pandora Dilemma
There are a couple ways the Democrats might respond to the recent wiretapping allegations. They might assess the situation based on a sober analysis of the facts and evidence available to them compliant with the standards of journalistic integrity. I jest, of course. They might also respond by doing everything in their powers to rebuke and ridicule the claims, effectively working to protect Obama from a serious public inquiry into the matter. If their standard pattern of behavior and initial reactions are any hint, they will pursue the route of legitimizing Obama's actions. But is that the wisest strategy for them?
Why Wiretap?
Note that these days the term wiretap is typically meant in the sense of a general interception of communications. Obviously a wireless phone is not literally wiretapped.
I showed in Mainstream Media Unsure How to Best Discredit Itself Over Wiretapping Situation that the Obama administration has a long history of wiretapping. Why would they do this? What benefits might be gained from intercepting the communications of a journalist or a political rival?
Danger warning
All politicians say they want honest and accurate journalism. But if some hypothetical entity was engaged in widespread unethical and illegal behaviors, they might become very concerned, even somewhat paranoid about journalists venturing too close to revealing their misdeeds. (Remember this is completely hypothetical). It is the priority of any shady politician to keep tabs on journalists and be forewarned of any impending scandals.
Competitive advantage
Intel always gives the recipient unfair competitive advantage. There are indications that information gleaned from surveillance made its way to the Clinton campaign. Such actions, if proven, would constitute a massive blow to the notion of a free election, and corroborate Trump's claim that it was rigged.
Political weaponry
Surveillance gives enormous leverage over the subject of interest. If the dubious observer just so happens to find evidence of criminal or embarrassing behavior, they can use that information to either blackmail or destroy their opponent.
Why Russia?
It seems that surveillance permission was granted to the Obama administration after their second application to the FISA courts. They did not make an attempt to get a surveillance order from a standard court. It would be nearly ludicrous to do so. To go on the record to ask for a warrant against the opposition party's candidate would be quite a scandal. But FISA warrants are issued in secret. That is the warrant you want if you're a shady politician trying to use surveillance as a weapon against an opponent. But the warrant is also very restricted in scope. Because it is effectively a violation of the 4th Amendment, the warrants are limited to foreign intelligence surveillance (the FIS in FISA) information necessary to protect the United States against "grave" "hostile" attack, war-like sabotage, or international terror. It's not enough for Obama to merely allege that Trump is generally a threat to the nation. There must be a concrete plot, either real or suspected, and of a foreign nature.
This is why we have the alleged Russian connection. If you've been baffled over their insistence on pushing this farsical inquisition, be baffled no longer. The Russian connection satisfied the need for the surveillance to be of a foreign nature. With that in place, surveillance was put on the Trump campaign in complete secrecy. This explains not only the pushing of the Russia conspiracy theory during the election, but why they are pressing hard on it still to this day. Once Trump was elected it became obvious that the surveillance would be exposed. They are desperate to keep the idea of Russian collusion planted in the minds of the public to have plausible deniability for using the state security apparatus against the political opposition, which is approximately the definition of tyranny.
The Dilemma
The situation facing the left is this. If they admit that the surveillance was improper then they pave the way for high-ranking former officials, and perhaps Obama himself, to be sent to prison. They almost certainly won't do this. They'll find every reason to deny or justify the surveillance. Obama probably won't go to jail. But then they've justified tyrannical behavior, and now Trump is president. The precedent will be made that to put surveillance on the political opposition, all one has to do is make vague accusations of collusion with a foreign entity and get a secret court order. So which is the better option for the left: Do they let their hero's legacy go down in flames? Or do they open the Pandora's box of legitimizing state tyranny under an administration they are quite certain is tyrannical?
Monday, February 27, 2017
That's So Republican
It's strange what a few months can do. A year or so I was using the word Republican as a pejorative, in the way we used to call things "gay" in high school. (And in college. And in the military.) At some point it became socially unacceptable to call things you don't like gay, so Republican seemed like a nice substitute. I mean what was more useless than a Republican anyway?
So it was unexpected that within six months I would be strongly supporting a Republican for president. Trumped picked fights with the media. With the globalists. With the Bushes and other establishment Republicans. He brutally savaged Hillary's character and record, which is what we expected out of Bernie the anti-corrupt. One thing about Trump was certain: he was picking fights with the right people!
Now we're over a month into the Republican supremacy. They have the presidency. They have both houses of Congress. Soon the Supreme Court will be conservative. They have the vast majority of the state houses and governors. Surely this is the opportunity Republicans have been dreaming of. Finally they can run the government the way they want, without the evil socialist Democrats stopping them! So how much legislation has our massively empowered Republican legislature passed in the 5 weeks of Trump?
Nada. No legislation. The Republican house, which voted to abolish Obamacare six times under certainty of veto by Obama himself, can't bring themselves to pass the same bill now that he's gone. Why? Because they want to be seen as fighting to stop government excess, without actually bearing the consequences of actually stopping government excess. They've ranted for years about the dangers of social healthcare but now that the ball is in their court they're revealed as either frauds, corrupt, or spineless. I think it's mostly the last one. They're afraid of being called bullies by liberals for taking healthcare from the destitute. Well you know what? The liberals are going to call you mean names no matter what you do. Have the Republicans learned nothing at all?
Leading the pack in all this is Paul Ryan. He is the biggest traitor in politics I have ever witnessed. After the Omnibus bill he should have been shunned by every single last Republican. Instead he easily won his re-election in Wisconsin. How painful to witness that. Isn't it interesting that the two on the ticket that gave Obama a nearly uncontested re-election, McCain & Ryan, have revealed themselves to be traitors to the Republicans? Can you list one achievement of either man that doesn't being with, "Helped the Democrats to....."? McCain actually forwarded damning and hilariously fraudulent private intelligence reports against Trump to the FBI; he is actively engaged in sabotaging the Republican president. McCain is a man who started his career by crashing every jet he ever got his hands on, and then was given the nickname "Songbird" by fellow POWs while in captivity. At best he has always been dead weight to this country, and at worst a lifelong traitor.
And just look at Ryan. That was his tough-guy photo shoot. Wisconsin how do you not just whither away in shame? He looks like a kid playing with daddy's weights. This photo op is every bit as fake as his politics. Memo to Ryan: curls are for girls. Even the women in my gym seem to prefer deadlifts and squats, god bless them. Ryan is pathetic in the gym and pathetic as a Republican congressman. Why America are we electing these worthless losers?
Now the Republicans are talking about not replacing Obamacare so much as renaming it. Their newest proposal includes removing the fines applied for not carrying insurance, and instead implementing a tax credit to those who do get insurance. IT'S THE SAME DAMN THING!! There are three conservative complaints against the healthcare situation right now.
And Trump himself has not been any great savior to conservatives. I think Ron Paul sums it up very well. Trump is a massive improvement over the status quo Republican, don't get me wrong. Unlike them, he's not a sellout and has a backbone. But the big problem with Trump is that in the context of the budget he is a borrow and spend liberal, like Bush, like Reagan. I actually support the policy, but from the viewpoint of accelerationism. I believe the only way to stop the tyrannical western democracies is for them to bankrupt themselves. But I don't think that is Trump's intention, nor the desire of most conservatives.
If Republicans don't get the job done this time.....I just don't think the conservatives in this country have much patience left for treachery and incompetence.
So it was unexpected that within six months I would be strongly supporting a Republican for president. Trumped picked fights with the media. With the globalists. With the Bushes and other establishment Republicans. He brutally savaged Hillary's character and record, which is what we expected out of Bernie the anti-corrupt. One thing about Trump was certain: he was picking fights with the right people!
Now we're over a month into the Republican supremacy. They have the presidency. They have both houses of Congress. Soon the Supreme Court will be conservative. They have the vast majority of the state houses and governors. Surely this is the opportunity Republicans have been dreaming of. Finally they can run the government the way they want, without the evil socialist Democrats stopping them! So how much legislation has our massively empowered Republican legislature passed in the 5 weeks of Trump?
Nada. No legislation. The Republican house, which voted to abolish Obamacare six times under certainty of veto by Obama himself, can't bring themselves to pass the same bill now that he's gone. Why? Because they want to be seen as fighting to stop government excess, without actually bearing the consequences of actually stopping government excess. They've ranted for years about the dangers of social healthcare but now that the ball is in their court they're revealed as either frauds, corrupt, or spineless. I think it's mostly the last one. They're afraid of being called bullies by liberals for taking healthcare from the destitute. Well you know what? The liberals are going to call you mean names no matter what you do. Have the Republicans learned nothing at all?
Leading the pack in all this is Paul Ryan. He is the biggest traitor in politics I have ever witnessed. After the Omnibus bill he should have been shunned by every single last Republican. Instead he easily won his re-election in Wisconsin. How painful to witness that. Isn't it interesting that the two on the ticket that gave Obama a nearly uncontested re-election, McCain & Ryan, have revealed themselves to be traitors to the Republicans? Can you list one achievement of either man that doesn't being with, "Helped the Democrats to....."? McCain actually forwarded damning and hilariously fraudulent private intelligence reports against Trump to the FBI; he is actively engaged in sabotaging the Republican president. McCain is a man who started his career by crashing every jet he ever got his hands on, and then was given the nickname "Songbird" by fellow POWs while in captivity. At best he has always been dead weight to this country, and at worst a lifelong traitor.
And just look at Ryan. That was his tough-guy photo shoot. Wisconsin how do you not just whither away in shame? He looks like a kid playing with daddy's weights. This photo op is every bit as fake as his politics. Memo to Ryan: curls are for girls. Even the women in my gym seem to prefer deadlifts and squats, god bless them. Ryan is pathetic in the gym and pathetic as a Republican congressman. Why America are we electing these worthless losers?
Now the Republicans are talking about not replacing Obamacare so much as renaming it. Their newest proposal includes removing the fines applied for not carrying insurance, and instead implementing a tax credit to those who do get insurance. IT'S THE SAME DAMN THING!! There are three conservative complaints against the healthcare situation right now.
- The federal government has no authority to be in the business of healthcare to begin with.
- The government can't force citizens to buy a product.
- The cost of healthcare is astronomical.
And Trump himself has not been any great savior to conservatives. I think Ron Paul sums it up very well. Trump is a massive improvement over the status quo Republican, don't get me wrong. Unlike them, he's not a sellout and has a backbone. But the big problem with Trump is that in the context of the budget he is a borrow and spend liberal, like Bush, like Reagan. I actually support the policy, but from the viewpoint of accelerationism. I believe the only way to stop the tyrannical western democracies is for them to bankrupt themselves. But I don't think that is Trump's intention, nor the desire of most conservatives.
If Republicans don't get the job done this time.....I just don't think the conservatives in this country have much patience left for treachery and incompetence.
Friday, February 17, 2017
All Costs to be Measured in Terms of Communism
When I was a college student (the first time) I used to drink a lot of beer. (I still do, but I used to too). In that era I got into the habit of making all cost-benefit analyses in terms of beer. The math was made especially easy thanks to Wednesday night being dollar beer night. So for instance if I was interested in a $27 dollar shirt, I would ask myself, "hmmmm, is this shirt really worth 27 beers?"
In hindsight it was a stupid comparison. Beer drinking was ultimately the frivolous activity, and I should have been making the judgment in the other direction. "Are these 27 beers really worth forgoing essentials like clothing and rent?"
I see this image constantly on my facebook feed. (Yes I realize my blog is quickly devolving to me just ranting about shit I see on facebook.)
It fails basic economics. Actually calling it economics is too generous. It fails rudimentary budgeting. And budgeting is just counting. So this meme fails at counting. It totally ignores that the wall will lead to less overall spending, not more. Illegal immigration costs the US over $100 billion a year. It fails cause and effect, which is the aspect of humanity that separates us from the animals. (Maybe not though; even my cat knows if I catch him on the countertop it will be spray bottle time.) Let's just use similar hypothetical scenarios of this "logic" in action.
In hindsight it was a stupid comparison. Beer drinking was ultimately the frivolous activity, and I should have been making the judgment in the other direction. "Are these 27 beers really worth forgoing essentials like clothing and rent?"
I see this image constantly on my facebook feed. (Yes I realize my blog is quickly devolving to me just ranting about shit I see on facebook.)
It fails basic economics. Actually calling it economics is too generous. It fails rudimentary budgeting. And budgeting is just counting. So this meme fails at counting. It totally ignores that the wall will lead to less overall spending, not more. Illegal immigration costs the US over $100 billion a year. It fails cause and effect, which is the aspect of humanity that separates us from the animals. (Maybe not though; even my cat knows if I catch him on the countertop it will be spray bottle time.) Let's just use similar hypothetical scenarios of this "logic" in action.
- Instead of buying equipment the boss could give us all massive raises.
- Instead of having plumbers fix the cascading water main dad could take us all to the circus.
- Instead of paying for critical infrastructure repairs the governor could give every kid a puppy.
The last example kind of stretches the qualifier of "hypothetical" if you live in California. But you get the point. Instead of doing capital investments or preventive maintenance we could just give shit away!
Just like I used to foolishly measure all my costs in terms of beer consumption, liberals now measure all government costs in terms of welfare spending. Providing homes to people, universal free education, free healthcare. If they achieve their goals then the only leftward step from there is nationalizing the means of production, I'd think. Basically the argument is "why pay for all this other crap that doesn't help my feelings when we could have sweet communism instead?"
Note: don't try making these arguments (or any arguments) to liberals. I mean you can do it if you want, and you can try teaching your dog French too, if that's how you like to spend your free time. I'd just say, "yeah and Obama could have paid for all that 7X with the $150 billion he handed over to Iran." Although to them Trump spending $20 billion on border control when we're swamped with illegal immigration is more wasteful than just handing $150 to a state sponsor of terror. You really can't reason with these people; only ridicule. Please do your part.
Thursday, February 16, 2017
Universality in the US
Universality is the principle from philosophy that morality judgments should be applied to all individuals and groups uniformly. In fact, we can often tell if there is injustice by inverting the parties involved to determine if the moral determination is altered. Consider the following scenarios.
- 96% of campaign donations by the media are directed towards the Republican party.
- Whites are given preferential access to colleges and jobs.
- Women receive 63% longer jail sentences than men for the same crime.
- Haiti engages in a bombing campaign against the US for not handing over the terrorist Emmanuel Toto Constant.
- Whites commit violent crimes at 7 to 10 times the rate of other races.
- Custody courts rule in favor of men 90% of the time.
- Iran maintains a heavy naval presence in the Gulf of Mexico to ensure oil makes it safely to market from Texan ports, and maintains numerous bases in Mexico, Cuba, and Canada to support them.
- Republicans routinely inflict violence on Democrats to suppress their freedoms of speech and assembly.
- European nations pay a heavy burden for the defense of NATO while the US pays very little.
- All non-white countries are expected to diversity their ethnic compositions. However white countries are free to remain homogeneous.
- Men host nationwide marches but women's rights advocates are widely ridiculed and condemned as misandrists.
- 20 million Americans enter northern Mexico illegally. They take jobs from the locals, enroll in social programs, and frequently vote in Mexican elections.
Do you think any of these scenarios would cause tremendous outrage in mainstream America? If so it might be the case that our society is driven by identity politics more than principles, which does not bode well for the long-term stability of the nation.
Tuesday, February 14, 2017
Immune Reaction of the Deep State
When our bodies are invaded by a virus we rarely experience its direct effects. The virus attacks our tissues directly, but everything we suffer: runny noses, itchy eyes, congestion, coughing, sneezing, headache, fever, body aches; result from the responses of the immune system. Each ailment plays some role in fighting the infection and keeping additional pathogens out.
[As as aside, to me this is all biological proof that we are genetically disposed to be assholes. Think of what happens when you're sick and you sneeze. Is that sneeze more likely to prevent additional infections from entering through your respiratory system, or to spread the illness you already have to the people around you?]
We are witnessing an analogous process in the political realm, as the deep state unleashes all sorts of ailments on the body politic to rid itself of what it perceives to be a great threat to either (a) itself or (b) the nation overall. (The answer is a but they'll always pretend it is b). The reactions range from irritating to harmful. From a complete loss of professionalism by the media to promotion of outlandish conspiracy theories against our nuclear rival, none of their responses could be remotely labeled as beneficial.
You might note that I include the media as part of the deep state. That they carry water for the deep state is nothing new and has been well documented by Noam Chomsky and others. Also this was confirmed from the DNC leaked emails that showed numerous news organizations were meeting in secret with Hillary Clinton just before she announced her candidacy. This is exactly what media collusion with the political side of the deep state would like.
Make no mistake there is a war brewing in our government, and numerous entities will stop at nothing to undermine the new leadership. How far will they go? When the body marks an antigen as an existential threat it will similarly stop at nothing to eradicate it. A peanut is not harmful. Quite the opposite it is a nutritious food. But if the immune system rejects peanuts it will mount a response so severe that it can even kill the body it is fighting to defend.
[As as aside, to me this is all biological proof that we are genetically disposed to be assholes. Think of what happens when you're sick and you sneeze. Is that sneeze more likely to prevent additional infections from entering through your respiratory system, or to spread the illness you already have to the people around you?]
We are witnessing an analogous process in the political realm, as the deep state unleashes all sorts of ailments on the body politic to rid itself of what it perceives to be a great threat to either (a) itself or (b) the nation overall. (The answer is a but they'll always pretend it is b). The reactions range from irritating to harmful. From a complete loss of professionalism by the media to promotion of outlandish conspiracy theories against our nuclear rival, none of their responses could be remotely labeled as beneficial.
You might note that I include the media as part of the deep state. That they carry water for the deep state is nothing new and has been well documented by Noam Chomsky and others. Also this was confirmed from the DNC leaked emails that showed numerous news organizations were meeting in secret with Hillary Clinton just before she announced her candidacy. This is exactly what media collusion with the political side of the deep state would like.
Make no mistake there is a war brewing in our government, and numerous entities will stop at nothing to undermine the new leadership. How far will they go? When the body marks an antigen as an existential threat it will similarly stop at nothing to eradicate it. A peanut is not harmful. Quite the opposite it is a nutritious food. But if the immune system rejects peanuts it will mount a response so severe that it can even kill the body it is fighting to defend.
Thursday, February 9, 2017
It's a War of Pyschologies, not Ideologies
The Anonymous Conservative made a post today that reinforces a recent post of mine. Quoting from the Chicago Tribune:
Here Rahm says it openly. Winning is everything. Principles be damned. Ideology be damned. Logical consistency be damned. Whether or not we choose to be principled or consistent is our own choice, but know this: it won't matter to them. They won't be impressed with our logic and they won't respect our principled approaches. It is a war being fought with sides drawn based on subconscious psychological drives.
Remember, when they go low, we go low. To them nothing matters besides winning. Nothing matters besides political power. And there is a lot of reason to be very afraid of what will happen when/if they regain political power. They've already determined violence is okay if they call us a fascist first. What will be next? These people must be kept in check with whatever means is available. Not for any principles, but because we are their enemy, and they have no principles.
As he did last month at an event in Washington, D.C., the mayor expanded on what he believes is the road map back to power for his party — putting moderate candidates such as veterans, football players, sheriffs and business people up in Republican districts, picking battles with Republicans, exploiting wedges within the GOP and fighting attempts to redistrict Congress on partisan grounds.From AC's commentary:
But this time he didn’t hold back on his frustration with some of his fellow Democrats.
“Winning’s everything,” he said…
Instead, he said, Democrats should focus on the GOP. “Wherever there’s a disagreement among Republicans, I’m for one of those disagreements,” he said. “I’m all for it. The president’s with Russia? I’m with John McCain and Lindsey Graham, I’m for NATO! Why? (It’s a) wedge. Wedges have to be schisms, schisms have to be divides.”
All of politics is r vs K. It is a battle of reproductive strategies. r-strategists want to destroy K-strategists. There are no morals, no ideals, no greater goals, no compassion, no decency – nothing else. This is about destroying what the left views as a hostile species they do not like. This is a war, every bit as real as the Allies vs the Axis, or radical Islam against the unbelievers.
His viewpoint is that politics is downstream not just of culture, but of deeply rooted psychologies, dubbed r and K from biological reproductive strategies. This isn't a battle of ideologies. The sides are drawn up at a deeper level, and the politics follows after. The left does this better (in a sense of the word better) than we do. I noticed this in one of my earliest blog posts. The left is unprincipled. Surely they'd say the same about us, but I counter they are objectively more so. In a political war that is an insult, but in a war of psychologies that is the strategy of fluidity. They don't care about principles, they care about damaging the other side, and making gains for their side.
Here Rahm says it openly. Winning is everything. Principles be damned. Ideology be damned. Logical consistency be damned. Whether or not we choose to be principled or consistent is our own choice, but know this: it won't matter to them. They won't be impressed with our logic and they won't respect our principled approaches. It is a war being fought with sides drawn based on subconscious psychological drives.
Remember, when they go low, we go low. To them nothing matters besides winning. Nothing matters besides political power. And there is a lot of reason to be very afraid of what will happen when/if they regain political power. They've already determined violence is okay if they call us a fascist first. What will be next? These people must be kept in check with whatever means is available. Not for any principles, but because we are their enemy, and they have no principles.
Monday, February 6, 2017
How to Dismantle the "It's My Body" Argument
I mention here a lot that the abortion debate is like a war where both sides are fighting different battles. The left sees it as a women's rights issue. The right either sees it as a moral argument that abortion is murder (has nothing to do with women as a political entity) or that Roe V. Wade is an unconstitutional ruling and is judicial overreach (again has nothing to do with women as a political entity). While I have my own reasons for supporting legalized abortion the pro-abortion arguments I hear tend to be illogical. Here is a simple way to dismantle one of the more common arguments you'll encounter.
After they make the claim of "my body, my right", ask them if they support partial-birth abortion. If they do, that's fine. They win the logical debate. They'll ultimately lose the battle for hearts and minds of the public if ultimately they advocate that women can interrupt the birthing process to stab the almost-infant in the head and suck out its brains.
If they don't support partial birth abortion, then the contradiction is this: if the woman can't choose to terminate the fetus while it's still inside her, then they must not actually care about the rights of her body. Prod for the point at which abortion becomes wrong. They'll usually say the third trimester. (Most European countries ban after the first trimester). Ask why body rights don't apply during the 3rd trimester. The abortion advocate won't be able to give a good answer, because there is not one.
If women's "rights to their bodies" is in fact a valid argument, then it must apply all the way until the bodies of mother and fetus are separated. That is, up to childbirth and the child's first breath. The abortion advocate must decide if they advocate the argument in full or not at all. Positions of the type "well it's her body except at the third trimester it suddenly becomes not her body (plus or minus two weeks)" are ultimately indefensible.
Here are some questions & quips you can make which will be effective, especially if there are observers to the interaction.
After they make the claim of "my body, my right", ask them if they support partial-birth abortion. If they do, that's fine. They win the logical debate. They'll ultimately lose the battle for hearts and minds of the public if ultimately they advocate that women can interrupt the birthing process to stab the almost-infant in the head and suck out its brains.
If they don't support partial birth abortion, then the contradiction is this: if the woman can't choose to terminate the fetus while it's still inside her, then they must not actually care about the rights of her body. Prod for the point at which abortion becomes wrong. They'll usually say the third trimester. (Most European countries ban after the first trimester). Ask why body rights don't apply during the 3rd trimester. The abortion advocate won't be able to give a good answer, because there is not one.
If women's "rights to their bodies" is in fact a valid argument, then it must apply all the way until the bodies of mother and fetus are separated. That is, up to childbirth and the child's first breath. The abortion advocate must decide if they advocate the argument in full or not at all. Positions of the type "well it's her body except at the third trimester it suddenly becomes not her body (plus or minus two weeks)" are ultimately indefensible.
Here are some questions & quips you can make which will be effective, especially if there are observers to the interaction.
- How many heartbeats does a body have?
- How many fingers and toes does a human body have?
- How many blood types can a body have?
- How many sets of DNA does a body have?
- Is it wrong when women say the baby kicked? Shouldn't they say, I kicked?
- Can mothers say the fetus is a boy when it's just part of the female body?
- Why are people convicted of murder if they use force to kill the fetus? Shouldn't these crimes be prosecuted as some sort of bodily harm?
Calexit: Sorry Liberals It's Not What Your Elites Want
I'm a sucker for secessionist movements. I supported Brexit and Texit. I support Hawaiian independence, a unified Ireland, and the free state of Bavaria. I want to see downstate Illinois divorced from it's Chicago overlord and I once advocated for my own Illinois county to secede from the union and align with Bavaria because of their superior beer laws and culture. Naturally I support Calexit, for reasons stated before.
However Calexit seems doomed to fail. And not just because of public polling that would seem to suggest little public support. The odds aren't that awful when you consider all the "Don't Knows" are open to persuasion. The problem is there is little energy behind the movement. Look at their subreddit. Only 2K subscribers and not much activity. Why is it that liberals are able to organize for national marches and riots but can't even get a small amount of energy for Calexit? It seems to me that those operations had support from the leftist establishment. Those activities are funded to the tune of millions of dollars and are given organizational support. Why doesn't Calexit get the same treatment? Obvious enough: the liberal elites don't want it.
I'm tempted to say the left has no grassroots action at all. The obvious counter example is Bernie. But even Bernie was initially propped up by the media, to try to counter accusations that Hillary was running virtually unopposed for the nomination. Sure he because so popular that they then had to rig the election against him, but one wonders where he'd be if the media had initially ignored him as they typically do with anti-establishment candidates. So the closest thing to a grassroots on the left is Bernie, but even he may have needed the establishment bump to get traction, and the establishment still nixed the movement when they had to. Everything else, the marches, riots, even the pipeline protests had organizational backing. Calexit does not.
The liberal elites don't want states' rights and they don't want geographical balkanization. They don't want an environment where people can live in areas that suit their culture and personal preferences. They want to dictate their vision for the perfect society to everyone. They want centralization of power, and to be the ones dominating it. So sorry liberals who support Calexit. As much as I like seeing so many of you coming around on states' rights, it won't happen because nothing in the left happens from the grassroots.
When They Go Low, We Go Low
Taking the high road may often by the best strategy, but refusing anything but the high road is a fool's errand and will lead to assured defeat. Let's take a look at why we should always be willing to "sink to their level".
You must defend the fronts on which you are attacked.
Not fighting is just a highly efficient method of losing. It is tempting to say, "We won't be drawn in to such a petty fight." Abstaining by virtue of a moral high-road is practically indistinguishable from surrender. Allowing the adversary to push on a front without response is the same as retreat. Retreat can be a powerful strategic tool, but it can't be the only strategic tool.
Liberals understand this. They always fight, even when it doesn't make sense to. Conservatives don't, because they are afraid of the liberal media. If doing the right thing was easy everyone would do it, but since it is such a rare trait, doing the right thing must in fact be dangerous and difficult.
In no domain is this more apparent than in education and the media. Conservatives have given all control of the the most important propaganda assets to their opponents. The only conservatives that seem to have dug in are the religious right, who demand that Creationism and other religious topics be taught in the schools. The more reasonable conservatives don't have the same conviction. And they've allowed the education sector to be totally dominated by the left, to the point where some pursuits, such as social sciences, have no conservative faction at all. See where being reasonable gets us?
The left pushes back on instinct. In fact, as I described in an earlier post, it is their defining quality. If the right stands against Roe V. Wade out of legal reasoning they push back with women's rights. Doesn't make sense does it? Nope, not at all. They're not even having the same discussion we are. Being reasonable is less important than having a casus belli. The left has had great success even though objectively their arguments suck.
The left fights back even when they contradict themselves. After years of calling the lack of federally mandated maternal leave another example of oppression against women, they actually attacked Trump when he made the proposal in his campaign. Insane? Yes. Effective? Considering their grip on the vital institutions like education and the media, yes, they are doing something right. Perhaps they are modern day Berserkers, but so what?
The right must adopt this mentality. They must instinctively defend any front unless there is some good reason not to. Who cares if they call us hypocrites? They call us hypocrites anyway. Who cares if they employ their SJW weaponery against us, calling us racist, sexist, etc? They do those things anyway. They will attack you whether or not you choose to defend yourself. The issue here is not one if intellectual or moral superiority, but a simple lack of courage and conviction.
You must employ the tactics that are used against you.
If your opponent deploys a previously shunned tactic that gives them an advantage, you must respond in kind. At the least, you must consider that the tactic is a viable weapon in your arsenal. If you're in a fist fight, you will like keep some level of civility to it. But if they go below the belt, you absolutely must return the tactic. If they are allowed to kick you where it counts but you don't allow yourself to use the same tactic, you will be at a marked disadvantage. And if your opponent knows they can fight dirty and you won't respond in kind, then you only encourage them to disregard all decorum.
Right now the left is winning the dirty deeds fights. The DNC has funded and organized highly illegal activities intended to damage the other side. And they've faced no legal repercussions for doing so. It would be foolish at this point for the right not to respond in kind. Why should they not have paid protesters show up to liberal events? Why should they not work to shut down rallies of their opponents? Because we're better than that?
This shouldn't imply that we blindly react. Of course restraint is its own virtue. Donald Trump could have responded to Hillary's insults of his base by insulting her base, but he "looked past the sale" and chose not to do so. Maybe he should have, but he came out on top of things. Today they are doing everything they can to provoke us into violence, but using violence against us. We are wisest to resist, because we know how they are using the media to in their favor. (Note if they didn't control the media then this would not be to their advantage. That's what we get for giving up that battlespace to begin with.) At this time it behooves us not to respond in kind, but we have specific reasons to disobey the general rule: always respond in kind.
Wars are never battles of ideas.
Ideas may fuel wars. Belligerents use ideas to underpin moral justifications. But ideas are just one front of the war. You can quite easily win the battle of ideas and lose the war. I see a lot of people complaining about meme warfare. It's low-brow and childish. Yes and it's highly effective. Trump may be the first man deliberately memed in to office. Memes are most effective when you have your logical arguments in place, which can guide the memer to make pithy laconic statements that efficiently convey powerful statements. But they don't have to be. The left's most viral meme right now is just ridicule of Kellyanne Conway. Memes don't have to convert; they can simply serve to boost morale for the embattled soldiers.
To win the battle of ideas but lose the fronts of emotion, self-interest, information, logistics, strategy & tactics, organization, communication, etc is to be utterly crushed in the war. When they go low, that is outside the realm of ideas or civil discourse, we must be able to defeat them in that domain as well. In fact the only thing ultimately to keep an opponent from "going low" is the fear they will suffer greatly for doing so. In face of defeat they will always resort to "low" tactics. This is perfectly natural and we should never be surprised at them.
Conclusion
Political wars will tend to spiral towards the bottom if no mutual or societal pressures exist to prevent it. We have a society built on rule of law meant to prevent this. But the inhibiting effect is only as strong as the enforcement. And if the rewards of violating convention exceed the punishment, then someone will violate. We can't control society, we can only operate within it. And if society is willing to permit uncouth behavior, we must use it so the other side cannot gain an unfair advantage over us, while at the same time working to build a society the effectively clamps down on the same behavior. It is not hypocritical to do so, and in fact is the only reasonable approach to these things.
Update
These ideas may be somewhat more mainstream than I though. They are largely influenced by Vox Day. He has a fairly large following, but that doesn't make him mainstream. I was surprised that when I caught the Mark Levin on my commute after writing this, the guest host Dan Bongino spent the beginning part of the show on this (2/6/17 podcast). He points out that the left reflexively fight on every issue, and the right doesn't. Very similar to what I wrote on the same day. Maybe he reads the blog? (traffic stats indicate not likely)
Another thing I didn't mention though is the the left is heavily Marxist these days, and in Marxism everything is politics. Art, literature, education, science, you name it: it is all just a front in oppression politics. So naturally they fight us everywhere, and we're slow to respond because they don't seem like political battles. They are.
Sunday, February 5, 2017
Troubling Revelation from the Yemen Raid
It's been over a week now since the Yemen raid that was, while successful in its objective, so troubled that is being largely labeled as a botched raid. In my first post on the subject I fell just short of condemning the operation because it does not seem to be in line with Trump's stated foreign policy or even the policy that has been in place. At this point we're still in the honeymoon phase with Trump and I'm willing to throw him some benefit-of-the-doubt while he establishes patterns of behavior. However in the past week the most troubling aspect of the whole incident has come to light: the media has largely left it alone.
That's not to say he hasn't be criticized and ridiculed for it. He certainly has. But nothing of the co-ordinated media blitzes we're used to seeing used against him. This operation opened a huge to flank to attack Trump on both foreign policy and military judgment. It could easily be spun to fit the media's depiction of him as brash and careless. But it was hardly even the biggest story of the week. Much more effort was spent on the narrative that Trump's teams is "in chaos." An even bigger story was the nonsense of Trump having belligerent phone with multiple foreign heads of state. The most viral thing I've seen out of the left this week is their ridicule of Kellyanne Conway for stating that it was a massacre in Bowling Green that led the Obama administration to impose travel restriction to some countries, rather than an averted massacre. It was primarily an exercise in pedantry, certainly no where near the magnitude of the Yemen raid in importance.
Why is the media laying off Trump when they have an actual legitimate reason to blast him? Clearly they must support his actions there. Or more like, the people driving the propaganda agenda support it. It is very troubling that the first action of the candidate with the anti-establishment foreign policy seems to be an establishment-approved operation. Is he being turned so soon? Or is this the learning curve at play? Certainly the same institutional forces that almost completely bent Obama to their will have been heavily lobbying Trump. If that is the case, then the silver lining of the botched raid may be to drive Trump to reject this kind of advice in the future, in the way that John F. Kennedy was said to have lost faith in CIA counsel after the botched Bay of Pigs operation.
That's not to say he hasn't be criticized and ridiculed for it. He certainly has. But nothing of the co-ordinated media blitzes we're used to seeing used against him. This operation opened a huge to flank to attack Trump on both foreign policy and military judgment. It could easily be spun to fit the media's depiction of him as brash and careless. But it was hardly even the biggest story of the week. Much more effort was spent on the narrative that Trump's teams is "in chaos." An even bigger story was the nonsense of Trump having belligerent phone with multiple foreign heads of state. The most viral thing I've seen out of the left this week is their ridicule of Kellyanne Conway for stating that it was a massacre in Bowling Green that led the Obama administration to impose travel restriction to some countries, rather than an averted massacre. It was primarily an exercise in pedantry, certainly no where near the magnitude of the Yemen raid in importance.
Why is the media laying off Trump when they have an actual legitimate reason to blast him? Clearly they must support his actions there. Or more like, the people driving the propaganda agenda support it. It is very troubling that the first action of the candidate with the anti-establishment foreign policy seems to be an establishment-approved operation. Is he being turned so soon? Or is this the learning curve at play? Certainly the same institutional forces that almost completely bent Obama to their will have been heavily lobbying Trump. If that is the case, then the silver lining of the botched raid may be to drive Trump to reject this kind of advice in the future, in the way that John F. Kennedy was said to have lost faith in CIA counsel after the botched Bay of Pigs operation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



